Why Is The Obvious Not So Obvious?

Hi FX on "a lot of traders get killed because they buy when price is falling because "it has to go back," and it never turns back and vice versa for selling" I can only say been there done that...

this said, any particular day the price will generally do one or more of the following things: move within a range (use the box), move to the next range (still the Box may come handy) do both.

YES!! I completely agree.

Price fluctuates! It's very prevalent in this low interest rate market environment. You can build a nice edge around the ranging nature of markets. Of course, as the environment changes, so will the price action.
 
Anything can happen, you're right. A good trader is nimble and trades what he see's, not what he believes. However, there's an edge to be found in being able to differ a breakout of resistance on the chart vs. resistance breaking because of stop hunting, or because of risk-off sentiment on China fears. Two different scenarios can cause price to do two very different things after the breakout.

Total agreement

RN
 
Read ScoobyStoo's posts, and the OP's replies, in your PDF.

I will give you another clue. Those in the know gave much more away in their early posts when they weren't so cagey.
This thread is pretty large. Could you give an upper page boundary as to how much YOU deemed relevant for you to understand what the obvious was? For example taking the opening post, how many pages initially would you think contained the bare essentials material for YOU to understand what the obvious is?

If I took away capital, edge, risk management, position sizing it didn't leave a lot in terms of what I understood trading was all about.
Interesting. Could the obvious be just to understand HOW to lose in a given market you are trading? And not just limited losses or coming close to break even, but really lose consistently.
 
Who cares VO, all we want it to do is move tomorrow :)

Seriously, in order to risk some money on AAPL for the medium to long term, then a more detailed analysis of the charts to try and identify where the big money is would be required.

There is a good deal of work in this, but the payoff can be well worth it.

Contrary to what most think and say, it is possible to get a fairly good picture of what the big money is thinking about AAPL direction, and you can then place your trades accordingly, but as with any trading, no gain without risk, so in order to make the "larger" profit on such a trade, it will be required to take on the "larger" risk at first and manage trade as required.

To reword your last post.

Scenario 1
If AAPL goes above 117.25 and closes above this value, then the odds of it going up some more are good and a long trade might have sufficient low risk.

Scenario 2
If AAPL goes below 107.15 and closes below this value, then the odds of it going down some more are good and a short trade might have sufficient low risk.

Scenario 3
As long as AAPL stays within this $10 range then I might be best to wait and see happens by month end - I can always daytrade it in the meantime for smaller risk trades.

J_S

View attachment 157062

Scenario 1 and 2 are too obvious. Might work just once, ...perhaps they might even work this time, but they can't work consistently, over time. A not so obvious trade that can work for infinity is to anticipate breakout of either end is a trap, and as soon as the trapped give up hope and are trapped out, ...then that not so obvious logic will repeat.
 
Scenario 1 and 2 are too obvious. Might work just once, ...perhaps they might even work this time, but they can't work consistently, over time. A not so obvious trade that can work for infinity is to anticipate breakout of either end is a trap, and as soon as the trapped give up hope and are trapped out, ...then that not so obvious logic will repeat.
Yes, but it depends on where exactly price is when it breaks out, in relation to where it has been - this is why those who ignore charts always get sucked in and wonder then what has just happened.

Odds..odds..odds..improve your odds at all times..I think the OP's first post will need to be looked at again.

J_S
 
Why Is The Obvious Not So Obvious?

I have read thru some of the recent and distant posts in this section, and have come to the conclusion that; the obvious is not so obvious to many!

There appears to be a lot of textbook information being thrown around, especially in relation to position sizing and risk management.

What every trader has to realise, is that all the risk management and position sizing techniques in the world are of no use what so ever, unless the trader is aware of the obvious pre-requisite to trading any market.

It will be very interesting to see what answers the many traders come up with for the obvious, those with little and lots of experience alike!

It is obvious what the OP posted, and some seem to have picked up on the important bits, while the majority didn't even bother to read the first post correctly!

So, the big question appears to be, what is the obvious pre-requisite to trading any market ?

J_S
 
So, the big question appears to be, what is the obvious pre-requisite to trading any market ?

J_S

Indeed J_S.

Some quotes from the OP about the "obvious":

"The obvious is simple, and it is because it is so simple that 99.999% do not even stop to try and work it out."

"If I gave the answer you would not believe me!"

"When a daytrader starts to trade live for to make a living, it is normal for everything that he/she has learned up to that point to fall apart. This will happen for several reasons, which we will probably get as many answers as traders, but it really happens due to one obvious reason, which is not so obvious!"


"However, knowing what is required, and knowing how to do it correctly, are not one in the same (that is actually a hint if read correctly)."

And RN:

"I predict that most will discount it once it is revealed - which is a shame in itself"

And TE:

'I am glad that the "gambling" bit has stuck in the head, for that is a must, but, the "obvious" is something that YOU need to know and master before YOU will make GOOD money, and it is sooooo OBVIOUS very few actually think about it, and go about reading tons and tons of useless shite, which, is just wasting time = money.'
 
Indeed J_S.

Some quotes from the OP about the "obvious":

"The obvious is simple, and it is because it is so simple that 99.999% do not even stop to try and work it out."

"If I gave the answer you would not believe me!"

"When a daytrader starts to trade live for to make a living, it is normal for everything that he/she has learned up to that point to fall apart. This will happen for several reasons, which we will probably get as many answers as traders, but it really happens due to one obvious reason, which is not so obvious!"


"However, knowing what is required, and knowing how to do it correctly, are not one in the same (that is actually a hint if read correctly)."

And RN:

"I predict that most will discount it once it is revealed - which is a shame in itself"

And TE:

'I am glad that the "gambling" bit has stuck in the head, for that is a must, but, the "obvious" is something that YOU need to know and master before YOU will make GOOD money, and it is sooooo OBVIOUS very few actually think about it, and go about reading tons and tons of useless shite, which, is just wasting time = money.'
Do you have an idea of what it might be E48 ?

J_S
 
Indeed J_S.

Some quotes from the OP about the "obvious":

"The obvious is simple, and it is because it is so simple that 99.999% do not even stop to try and work it out."

"If I gave the answer you would not believe me!"

"When a daytrader starts to trade live for to make a living, it is normal for everything that he/she has learned up to that point to fall apart. This will happen for several reasons, which we will probably get as many answers as traders, but it really happens due to one obvious reason, which is not so obvious!"


"However, knowing what is required, and knowing how to do it correctly, are not one in the same (that is actually a hint if read correctly)."

And RN:

"I predict that most will discount it once it is revealed - which is a shame in itself"

And TE:

'I am glad that the "gambling" bit has stuck in the head, for that is a must, but, the "obvious" is something that YOU need to know and master before YOU will make GOOD money, and it is sooooo OBVIOUS very few actually think about it, and go about reading tons and tons of useless shite, which, is just wasting time = money.'

Most likely, the "obvious" that the OP mentions is concerned with tracking the behaviour and intent of the large players and inferring that from price charts. If you can't do that then you may as well place trades with a random direction near to easily identified levels.
 
Back
Top