Cynthia Tomain who is well respected said the things that Chipshottrader is saying are falseHonestly, can't you really, Bam123?
I have no horse in this race at all, but surely you can see that people in a field with such a widespread questionable reputation as this, effectively claiming to have been awarded three PhD's in three different subjects in a decade, and implying that they've taught at a university at which it turns out they'd simply addressed a student society meeting are going to have their credentials questioned in public, if that information comes out?
Nothing personal, and absolutely no offense intended at all, but I can't help wondering whether "not knowing why such a person is being attacked" is possibly just a little on the naive side?
Tim Morge and the well-chosen example
- Thread starter Maverick1
- Start date
- Status
Sure. And Tim Morge has 3 Phds (Economics, Physics, Mathematics), obtained in the last 10 years, and mentioned throughout the IB webinars. And Cynthia Tomain can provide irrefutable proof of the existence of these degrees (i.e. official transcripts), because she did the proper due diligence...
I spoke with Cynthia, and she is a good person, caught in the middle of an unpleasant situation, which most definitely directly affects her employment at IB.
All I have provided are facts and thorough evidence, or as user “van_der_voort_4” refers to: BRILLIANT WORK...
Finally, below is Tim Morge’s website from 2008:
http://web.archive.org/web/20080216004820/http://www.blackthornecapital.com:80/btnewindex.html
Unless Mr. Morge got 3 Phds in the last 10 years, he is completely making up his credentials, which is grounds for dismissal in ANY FIELD. He would be fired from anywhere, on the spot.
Last edited:
%%Honestly, can't you really, Bam123?
I have no horse in this race at all, but surely you can see that people in a field with such a widespread questionable reputation as this, effectively claiming to have been awarded three PhD's in three different subjects in a decade, and implying that they've taught at a university at which it turns out they'd simply addressed a student society meeting are going to have their credentials questioned in public, if that information comes out?
Nothing personal, and absolutely no offense intended at all, but I can't help wondering whether "not knowing why such a person is being attacked" is possibly just a little on the naive side?
I dont know why[for sure,LOL] they are attacking him?? But i guess sometimes when i dont know for sure; overpriced vendors are sure to be hated. And his free stuff ,i did not get anything out of it. His Amos... golden whale pattern may have worked 4 years ago; but i could not get any more info on it, so a small sample may or may not work well?? I only listened to 20% of his video, but did speed read on years of his online cryptic stuff ....... His halfway line could help, but that already been published ,way before his post.
It's certainly a well evidenced phenomenon of "forum life" that when a vendor's credentials are called into question, a brand new member immediately joins and posts repeatedly only in that thread, looking for all the world as if their sole purpose of becoming a member was to offer some attempted defense and rebuttal (often not too easily or convincingly, to put it mildly).
I've always thought it a strange reason to join a forum, with no other apparent desire or reason for participation at all.
I've always thought it a strange reason to join a forum, with no other apparent desire or reason for participation at all.
Thank you SO VERY MUCH. Again, it was a team effort, ignited by the user who posted about Shane Blankenship’s recent bankruptcy (Timothy Morge’s partner at Market Geometry). It took months to tie all the dots together, and the Wayback Machine sealed the deal. Case Closed...
Wayback Machine is Awesome!!!
http://web.archive.org/web/20080216004820/http://www.blackthornecapital.com:80/btnewindex.html
It is true that I have only posted on this thread but I am certainly not a shill for market geometry. I am a member of market geometry trying to learn about median lines. And trying to discover if what’s being said on this thread is true I contacted Cynthia and she responded in the way I’ve already posted.
Little Reminder (Again!):
Sure. And Tim Morge has 3 Phds (Economics, Physics, Mathematics), obtained in the last 10 years, and mentioned throughout the IB webinars. And Cynthia Tomain can provide irrefutable proof of the existence of these degrees (i.e. official transcripts), because she did the proper due diligence...
I spoke with Cynthia, and she is a good person, caught in the middle of an unpleasant situation, which most definitely directly affects her employment at IB.
All I have provided are facts and thorough evidence, or as user “van_der_voort_4” refers to: BRILLIANT WORK...
Finally, below is Tim Morge’s website from 2008:
http://web.archive.org/web/20080216004820/http://www.blackthornecapital.com:80/btnewindex.html
Unless Mr. Morge got 3 Phds in the last 10 years, he is completely making up his credentials, which is grounds for dismissal in ANY FIELD. He would be fired from anywhere, on the spot.
Shane Blankenship’s Bankruptcy (teacher of Market Maps):
https://www.open-public-records.com/court/nevada-14952360.htm
Are you talking about chipshoptrader?
All of Chippy's ET posts are about Tim Morge and the way chippy keeps repeating time and again the same accusations has my BS meter registering BS.
Maybe chippy is the villain here?
Repeat BS enough times and everyone wants to believe it.
Last edited:
It is very boring to read same old stories that Tim has no Phd's and he has an expensive classes.
But I will play along for now. So let's say he has no Phd's, he has no offshore fund (which you can't find and what you presented was US based fund), no billions to manage, and all the other BS you wrote here.
What I care about is: Does his methods work? Can I make money with the tools? Are his methods stressful? What about his money-management?
I don't know about other members, but I tried to apply all Tim's methods (not all of them, because we learn more advanced tools when time flies) and I found out, that they make sense. What did you find?
If you expect to make money after two years of learning, you are a fool sir (you can expect to be break even tho. It is a slow process. It takes a big chunk of time every day. But I can tell you, it is worth learning.
I would like to comment on your archive link, I can see, that Tim made about 30% each year in his US based fund.. I don't know about you, but those are very nice numbers. (are yours better?)
I took the risk, tried what he is teaching, and I can see the logic and consistency for years.. Trading is not for everybody and not everybody can make it.
Also show me some hard proofs (which you will never find) or stop.
But I will play along for now. So let's say he has no Phd's, he has no offshore fund (which you can't find and what you presented was US based fund), no billions to manage, and all the other BS you wrote here.
What I care about is: Does his methods work? Can I make money with the tools? Are his methods stressful? What about his money-management?
I don't know about other members, but I tried to apply all Tim's methods (not all of them, because we learn more advanced tools when time flies) and I found out, that they make sense. What did you find?
If you expect to make money after two years of learning, you are a fool sir (you can expect to be break even tho. It is a slow process. It takes a big chunk of time every day. But I can tell you, it is worth learning.
I would like to comment on your archive link, I can see, that Tim made about 30% each year in his US based fund.. I don't know about you, but those are very nice numbers. (are yours better?)
I took the risk, tried what he is teaching, and I can see the logic and consistency for years.. Trading is not for everybody and not everybody can make it.
Also show me some hard proofs (which you will never find) or stop.
Dear “themickey”,
“Xela” is referring to user “Bam123” in her post, and she can fully confirm that. I just noticed user “Banger00” just registered at ET, and liked your post. So, basically we have “Bam123” and “Banger00”, who are simply here to distract viewers from the actual facts.
Please review the thread in its entirety to get an idea of the level of input that came from various members, starting with “Maverick”’s initial observation of Morge’s fairy tale trading examples.
“Fibronacci”’s input regarding Shane Blankenship’s recent bankruptcy is what made me focus on this thread exclusively, and then tie all the dots together through the Wayback Machine. There is absolutely nothing BS about, what all as a group, have gradually found out about Morge (with solid evidence to back it up).
“Xela”’s several common sense comments are right on point.
The only villain, and a major one at that, is Morge, for making up his credentials, and certainly a lot more...
Little Reminder (Just one more time!):
Sure. And Tim Morge has 3 Phds (Economics, Physics, Mathematics), obtained in the last 10 years, and mentioned throughout the IB webinars. And Cynthia Tomain can provide irrefutable proof of the existence of these degrees (i.e. official transcripts), because she did the proper due diligence...
I spoke with Cynthia, and she is a good person, caught in the middle of an unpleasant situation, which most definitely directly affects her employment at IB.
All I have provided are facts and thorough evidence, or as user “van_der_voort_4” refers to: BRILLIANT WORK...
Finally, below is Tim Morge’s website from 2008:
http://web.archive.org/web/20080216004820/http://www.blackthornecapital.com:80/btnewindex.html
Unless Mr. Morge got 3 Phds in the last 10 years, he is completely making up his credentials, which is grounds for dismissal in ANY FIELD. He would be fired from anywhere, on the spot.
Shane Blankenship’s Bankruptcy (teacher of Market Maps):
https://www.open-public-records.com/court/nevada-14952360.htm
Kind Regards,
Chippy
Last edited:
- Status