Quote from Vienna:
...I mean- it is easy to hide in an internet forum and throw mud at people...
First of all, I don't use JH method nor will I attempt to learn it because of my satisfaction with my own method.
However, you've been here a little longer than me and you must have seen what had occurred at ET involving Jack Hershey
prior to him revealing his method.
I do remember and it was ugly.
He had a different alias (at least two) back in those days and he was
consistently taking threads off-topic, personal attacks, arguing and continuing hijacking of many threads.
Many ET members asked him to stop and he just continue and continue.
Soon there was this animosity towards the guy by many ET members and I could tell they were just
waiting for an opportunity of pay back.
That opportunity occur when he revealed his method.
I believe he had been banned once (other alias) for something he said to a moderator or Baron...I could be wrong.
Anyways, he cleaned up his act a little and then decided to reveal his methodology.
Instead of debating with Jack via their actual aliases of prior debates with him...
Some simply created new aliases that had the purpose of attacking every single word from him.
To do that there were some members spending their entire day at ET waiting for the guy to post a message.
Stalking and acting more psychotic.
It does not matter Jack and gang doesn't post any brokerage statements nor realtime calls or ignore challenges.
It also doesn't matter that those literally pointing the finger at him do not post their own brokerage statements nor realtime calls especially the ones that have said once or twice they themselves are profitable via whatever method they use.
My point, you really need to understand how all of this got started to understand the
obsession some have with attacking Jack.
Thus, the
issue is not his method although some naive new ET members may think that all of the debates/attacks is all about his method.
Jack started this crap many years ago under a prior alias and some ET members can't let it go along with allowing themselves to get lost in the merits of his method which is just a facade to validate what they are doing...
Stalking for revenge.
Yet, I did not like it back in those days when Jack was doing what he was doing nor do I like what some ET members are doing what they are doing today via stalking the guy.
Both sides are equally guilty in creating today's mess...
It's so messed up that apologies from both sides can't fix it and that's mainly due to the
problematic moderating back in those years that still exist today.
However,
one solution posted in feedback many years ago that didnt' get one response from a moderator nor Baron...
As soon as there's a debate between someone and Jack or those that use his method...
Setup a hidden ignore profile in which those particular members can no longer see each other message posts considering both sides do not have the ability on their own to ignore the other.
I know the above is possible because I moderate at another location that does just that...although not perfect...it does improve the posting environment.
Mark