Quote from stu:
'Anything as possible' is not logically irrelevant. Hans, it is logically contradictory. The Impossible is not Possible - if it is , then it was never actually Impossible
.
Likewise there can be no Supernatural, because if there is, then it was actually always Natural.
stu
Hans,Quote from Hansel H:
"Anything is possible" isn't easy so easy to dispose of when we're dealing with that in the realm of the unknown which may or may not be. We can't know what's impossible in the unknown or even if anything is impossible in the unknown and so we must consider The Impossible as a subset of The Possible in that realm. Thus, in the realm of the unknown even The Impossible is only a possibility and therefore part of The Possible. In other words, to speak of The Impossible in the realm of the unknown is nonsensical. In the realm of the unknown anything is possible.
Again, in the realm of the unknown, we can't know whether or not there is that which may be forever beyond our ken even though it's presence is felt in our known world. It's possible that we may reach a limit determined by our thinking processes in our ability to describe things in the unknown that manifest themselves in our known world through their effects on the known world. Merely being aware of the existence of these things in the unknown that manifest through effects in the known isn't sufficient to incorporate them in the known/natural world. It's fair to categorize these possibilities as the Supernatural because we would have no way to incorporate them into the known/natural world. The Supernatural, like anything else in the unknown, is possible.
Quote from Hansel H:
Accepting the possibility of the Supernatural isn't a threat to reason. The door doesn't swing open to any and all preposterous explanations for the world. It's precisely because anything's possible that any particular scenario out of the myriad possible scenarios must be justified by supporting evidence and logical consistency if that particular scenario is to chosen over all the other possibilities.
Quote from Hansel H:
"Anything is Possible" makes it more difficult, not less difficult, for those arguing for preposterous explanations.

Quote from stu:
In the realm of 'the Supernatural' if anything is possible then that same anything is equally impossible. Nothing possible without it also is equally impossible.
If that anything was always possible, Naturally, it was always possible. Always impossible, then likewise naturally, always impossible.
It is clear that anything is not always possible or impossible Supernaturally.
There really can be nothing which is is Supernatural. It will always be Natural, no matter how bizarre..
Quote from Compulsive:
:eek:
You are what you believe