B15 thru b38.PP3 on b15.Ba on b20.PP4 on b22.BM REV on B24.BM REV on b27.PP1 on b29.Ac and BM REV on b33.BO T1 on b35.PP1 on b38. Interesting is b31,b32 or b33 are not BO T1 since never got a T1. http://screencast.com/t/hOrsyp6H
Deciphering Jack Analysis Bar by Bar ll
- Thread starter workwithus
- Start date
Do we have the same understanding of n+1 then?
The first n+1 test is for an EE of the C or F bands, after the first T2F occurs (C Band is established). Later when Bands H and K arrive with T2P/T2F triplets, they have their own n+1 test for either H or K band EE's. If the test is false for the Band EE's we are testing for, even if another EE would normally be triggered, such as Ba, we do not annotate it and the trend continues.
The first n+1 test is for an EE of the C or F bands, after the first T2F occurs (C Band is established). Later when Bands H and K arrive with T2P/T2F triplets, they have their own n+1 test for either H or K band EE's. If the test is false for the Band EE's we are testing for, even if another EE would normally be triggered, such as Ba, we do not annotate it and the trend continues.
Yes this is my current understanding.
Not sure about this comment because of numerous recent examples in jack's charts that say otherwise. Here's a few B band triggers after the C band is created.
http://screencast.com/t/lNt2b4zg http://screencast.com/t/CgX5Im7hg
Here's alot of A band triggers after the B band is created. http://screencast.com/t/ifXHBw1f http://screencast.com/t/eWbufwna http://screencast.com/t/JcMyvoLiUQg http://screencast.com/t/1Kb8kcGv3B http://screencast.com/t/IWsfQMtAHdm http://screencast.com/t/npkTkrPP http://screencast.com/t/os2H9uKX0
I understand that A Band can trigger after B Band, because there is no n+1 test for B Band. What is difficult for me to understand is how we can ever get the T2P T2F triplets required for the last bands, if any T2P repeat is going to cause Ba.
I initially assumed the n+1 test for a band was only done on the next bar, and then all EE's are possible again, but the example with an Ba directly following a T2F puzzles me. I've been over the n+1 posts several times, I'll try to re-read again and see if it clicks this time.
From what i can see on jack's latest charts the A band EE's can trigger up to the C band being created.The one i found past the C band may be a annotation error. As for B band EE's triggering after the C band i'm not sure since i found two recent examples. The Fd has the same parameters as the Ab (less than the T1) but comes after the C band is created. Jack appears to have just renamed the Ab.
Okay, so if T2F occurs, the next bar is tested for trend continuation. In order for this to occur, the volume on the next measurable bar needs to be bounded by T1 and T2F. This bar is labeled P3F.
So, we have P3F. A possible case of T2P to T2F to T2P exists, as quoted above. How do we get a second T2P without causing Ba? I can't understand how because T2P repeat would be greater than last T2P and less than P2, which is Ba Band Pass.
Edit to remove excess info
Whole day. Carryover is looking for first P2. http://screencast.com/t/EhGxcHS75BRO
