wrongful-death settlement, taxes and trusts

Taxes? So you are telling me that a civil suit system where awarded funds are subsequently taxed is not anything one should speak up against and call bullshit? How much more ridiculous can it get?

Read the question from OP.
Courts decided in favor of payment.
Where did OP ask for 50 opinions about whether the court's decision was correct?
Where's your grand idea about how to avoid the taxes? Oh, you forgot that was the real question by the OP. You'd rather ramble & argue for hours about bla, bla, bla that he has no interest in.
Please continue you rambling. Sorry I interrupted with an actual answer to his question.
 
Taxes? So you are telling me that a civil suit system where awarded funds are subsequently taxed is not anything one should speak up against and call bullshit? How much more ridiculous can it get?

It is the forum in which you bring it up. You are soapboxing about an issue you fiercely believe in, in an entirely inappropriate thread.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bum
Thank you. Yes, that's one avenue we looked at. Up to $15k/yr can be gifted without taxation. Which won't be enough to even pay for her college-tuition. I'm exploring inheritance hierarchy where default heir can renounce their claim and pass onto next (my brother and I). However, that still doesn't avoid tax-issues when that arises when we go to transfer that money to daughter.

If your Dad pays for the college tuition, is that necessarily a "gift"?
If he pays for apartment rent, is that a "gift"?

I don't know, just curious if it's a way around the tax if those payments aren't considered a "gift".
Might want to find out the definition of a "gift" according to tax laws.
 
Of course I made an estimate, never claimed otherwise. And this has nothing to do with democracy. Or were people initially consulted to vote for a civil suit system. Or did people decide on untrained jurors who wrongly decided in thousands of cases when someone's life was at stake? Thousands of decisions that you now take as unchangeable were decided without democracy in mind. Guess what, for example the second amendment is called an amendment. It means the constitution was amended at some point. Laws you claim are just there and can't be changed can in fact be changed. But it takes people to inform the cattle class that an inferior status quo does not have to remain so.

So you accuse me of pulling stuff out of my ass when you make all sorts of claims about my company? You never posted an image of your work setup. Not one of your claimed educational credentials. Yet everywhere you boast what an awesome entrepreneur you are. And then you pull stuff out of your own ass about others being in business or not. I smell hypocrisy.



So in other words, you pulled the numbers in your earlier post out your ass. You apparently don't understand the concept of democracy. You seem to be conflating civil liability in general with civil liability in the case of wrongful death. And you have absolutely no fucking clue what it takes to start and run a business anywhere let alone in the US. Those of us who are entrepreneurs have done very well for ourselves, thank you. We sure as hell don't cower in fear of civil suits as you apparently would, if you lived in the US and if you were an entrepreneur. But then neither of those apply to you, do they? So again, your irrelevant opinion is noted. Now take a chill pill before you give yourself an aneurysm.
 
If your Dad pays for the college tuition, is that necessarily a "gift"?
If he pays for apartment rent, is that a "gift"?

I don't know, just curious if it's a way around the tax if those payments aren't considered a "gift".
Might want to find out the definition of a "gift" according to tax laws.
That's another good idea! He would have to adopt her as his own kid in order to count her tuition on his taxes. Then when she turns 18, it's no longer deductible.

At some point, she needs to learn to manage her own money. Buying her own cars, houses, etc. Just trying to make my brother's money go as far as possible.

Looked into Dynasty Trust, but it's restrictive to descendants.
 
That's another good idea! He would have to adopt her as his own kid in order to count her tuition on his taxes. Then when she turns 18, it's no longer deductible.

At some point, she needs to learn to manage her own money. Buying her own cars, houses, etc. Just trying to make my brother's money go as far as possible.

Looked into Dynasty Trust, but it's restrictive to descendants.

Directly from IRS website, college tuition not taxed.
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/smal...ed/frequently-asked-questions-on-gift-taxes#2
Taxes.png
 
Thank you for asking, in fact I already answered some of your questions:

1) I would ask the state/government to hold them accountable. Beyond that I would forgive. My family, me included, have forgiven the doctor who committed malpractice and most likely took away valuable months if not years from my dad. The doctor lost his license to practice for good reason, he performed poorly and did not take his job seriously enough. That is enough. I bet the person who ran a red light has done jail time. All other things are forgivable and can be managed by the family just as we have done.

2) see 1)

Your point Re taxes is moot. If the law sees the annual payments for the daughter as a gross payment then taxes are rightly due, just as your deceased brother had to pay income taxes before making payments to his daughter. If the law decides those are net payments then they should not be taxed. Everything else is bullshit and you should sue the IRS or live in a jurisdiction where reasonable practices are applied. At some point humans need to decide, do they pay their fair dues or do they cheat and try to always game the system as much as possible. If the payment was meant to be a payment that the daughter was to receive net then it should never be taxed. What does the legal decision state?

What would you do in situations such as this:

1. someone accidently kills a loved one in your family through neglect. That is, they messed up.
2. it is proven 100% with video and eye-witness testimony that they were responsible

Would you roll over "oh well" and just go on with your life?
Note there's difference between compensatory vs. punitive damages.


Although my question has more to do with taxes. Have you ever willingly wrote cheque for double your taxes due and donated extra to tax-man???
 
Last edited:
Back
Top