Why do traders find it difficult to make money?

Here is how I scalp grabbing profits and just don't worry about what happens afterwards. Three trades this morning. All winners. I give my rationale or thinking for each trade so you can see what I am thinking and why I took the trade. These ended up being multiple points gained.

See this kind of scalping can go on all session long. Grabbing what the market gives. Using proper SL placement. Sure there will likely be some losses through the session but if one can maintain a win rate of 70% to 80% with this kind of scalping then it is a feasible way of making money. \

Concerning SLs I put them far enough out (based on PA and Volatility of the moment) to give the trade a chance to work in my favor without bleeding to death from 1000 paper cuts. However, that doesn't mean I will take the entire SL. If I see conditions change I will exit quickly with a smaller SL than my initial SL. But I want an initial SL (bigger) in there for some unexpected reason that makes the market surge or plunge. We can never know what factors may enter in and move the market. There is uncertainty in trading and we have to learn to embrace that and at the same time make money while simultaneously protecting ourselves.

Back to trading as I have already missed more scalps typing this.

Note: Short entries are red. Covering short entries are blue. Long entries are green. Exiting longs are orange.

View attachment 346082
Good Morning volpri,

I love it and thank you very much for showing some trades and delivering simple practical ways to make money in the markets.

One of things I struggle with and I think a lot of traders (I think @padutrader struggle as well ) struggle with, wanting certainty before trading.

In other words, I use to want and seek proof of concept (trading method) before I take action. And expect profits instantly. Or seeking certainty in how I am trading.

But I recall someone (I think Al Brooks) saying "Traders always swim in a sea of uncertainty everyday".

I removed the need of uncertainty and just simply fail in love with ES price movements day to day, just simply do my best rather I win, lose or stay in drawdown for X days/weeks.

I had to realize that there is no secrets, there is no setups, there is no nothing that is going to guarantee me money in my bank account other then myself, not doing stupid crap, and having fun guessing day to day with ES.

My experience, My XX clicks/trades per day with price and predicting how price will behave within the next 5 seconds to 60 minutes is my only faith or Edge for making money in the ES markets.

ES Futures Market is a Blessing from God.
 
I think we have all been there and done that, to some degree. It can be disheartening. That is why I strongly suggest a trader start small and do it all on a sim first many, many times (not just a few times but 100's of time maybe 1000's of times). A trader has to give himself time to learn, time to practice and work through all the issues that have to be dealt with. Not only must a strategy or technique prove itself out going forward (on a SIM), not backtesting (I do not use backtesting) but the strategy or technique must fit one's personality too.

For instance, I am too impatient for investing in say a mutual fund where someone else makes the decisions. I am too controlling. I am too detailed. If I win or lose then I have to know it is ME. If I lose I am just not yet good enough so more practice is in order. More forward testing must be done until a technique proves itself to work over multiple market conditions. If I win I can congratulate myself for working through issue and techniques to have finally find something that fits and works for me.

But it is important to myself that I bear the full responsibility for my wins and losses. It does me nary a benefit blaming the feds or blaming market manipulation. It only hurts more and worse than that it poisons my mind. That poison can become so pervasive that it is very hard to transcend.

The market is not out to "get" me. But I am out to get a piece of it! I have to just learn and practice until I can have the confidence that I can achieve that and at the same time survive losses.

The reason I suggest SIM trading to new traders is because there is no sense (in my books) in just throwing money at the market until the trader has confidence in the techniques he has practiced. Then once trading live starts the emotions will become involved and the psychology of trading will certainly come to the forefront and test the traders mettle and test his techniques all over again. That is where one must work through those issues and learn to stay the course and if doubts arise (and they will) go back to practicing on a SIM. There is no law saying a trader must trade live. Yet to succeed one has to be passionate about it and practice and persist.

There is light at the end of the tunnel!
I took your advice to heart. Thanks @volpri.

Paper traded on TOS from July to Oct 2023, then live for 3 months, and back to paper from Jan 2024 to now.

Also took someone else's advice, started to paper trade butterflies, both regular and BWB.
 
Here is my last trade for a bit has I have to run to town and do some errands. I moved around some of my annotations of the earlier 3 trades so as to make some room for this annotation for trade #4.

See once price starts a TR then I must change techniques. Since price is usually in a sideways move around 70% of the time in a session these TR can be quite profitable by fading tops and bottoms of them. Many traders will not trade them as they deem it noise. My posture is that there is no noise in the markets. Only movement. Techniques must be developed to capitalize on those movements. There are a few rules and things I look at while trading TRs.

1) 20 bars sideways to down in a bull market. sideways to up in a bear market. When I say market I am talking about the context of the previous trend (if any).

2) The range must be broad enough for at least a min scalp which I consider 1 point. This is explained in the next two concepts.

3) Not only must #2 be true but most of the bars in the TR must be at least the size of a min scalp.

4) The range must be at least 3x as broad and most of the bars (i.e.) the average size bar.

5) I have other techniques for trading TRs but if using the technique of fading the tops and bottoms of the TR then I will begin entries in the upper or lower 1/3 of the TR. That is: Shorting in the top 1/3 and going long in the bottom 1/3.

6) I want to see doji's and overlapping bars in the range as that indicates two-sided trading taking place. I prefer to see moves up and down within the TR.

7) When fading tops I will often scale in and exit on any move towards the center line of the range. Remember I am scalping (what some call noise LOL) and am not in it for a big homerun. Just look at this 4th trade. After my last exit it went on down through the center line of the TR but I was out with my profit. Sure I could have held for more but it could just as easy have turned up after my last exit. Besides if it goes on down which it did after my last exit will I short more? No! not without a very good reason like (like very strong mom). Instead, I am out with a profit and since it continued down I will now look to go long in bottom 1/3. I could have done so the very next 2 bars after my last exit and made more as it moved up and through the center line. But I didn't take that trade as I was too busy typing up this pretty chart LOL.

8) I will continue fading tops and bottoms scaling in when appropriate until there is a successful BO of the TR. What constitutes a successful BO is already in my journal if I recall.

If you like scalping 1 to 8 points in ES then this may interest you. Good luck! Henry Ford once said: "the harder I work the luckier I get!" Put in the work! Take the time to learn trading first on a SIM then live. If you can't make it work on a SIM it certainly won't work live.

Note: Notice my three scaled in short entries fading the top of the TR and my 3 scaled out exit as price moves towards center of the range. Grab those profits! (I am being nice here using palatable talk when saying "scaled in" ...it really is "averaging down" LOL the one rule drilled into us from the infancy of our trading experience as the one thing NOT to do.) I also watch the bar timer ...orange box top right as bar are forming. I like to how price is doing towards the last few seconds of the bar. It tells me who wins that bar, bears or bulls, and I can be johnny on the spot to execute a trade right at or after the close of the bar.

2nd Screenshot 2024-08-08 120310.png
 
Last edited:
I took your advice to heart. Thanks @volpri.

Paper traded on TOS from July to Oct 2023, then live for 3 months, and back to paper from Jan 2024 to now.

Also took someone else's advice, started to paper trade butterflies, both regular and BWB.
I have never traded options. Just not my thing. But keep up the paper trading. If you make it work there you can make it work live. At least the odds will be in your favor.
 
I couldn't agree more and sad that it took me so long to figure this out... big ego me use to excelling at everything I put effort into I guess.

I've had some good traders from this forum reach out and offer advice but it's just not enough. Really need constant guidance to be excellent at anything and with trading you're either excellent or losing money, no in between.

I've since completely quite trading and used remaining capital to buy another house. Real estate is literally easy mode path to wealth compared to trading and I have close family that are beyond helpful in this realm.

Once cash flow is better I may return to trading, idk...I miss it that's for sure.
Welcome back.
 
I have never traded options. Just not my thing. But keep up the paper trading. If you make it work there you can make it work live. At least the odds will be in your favor.
Thanks. Your homework assignment for paper trading is hard work!

So far, paper trades are net positive. I have about 9 months' statistics, daily, about 60% of scalps are winners, 3 out of 4 days are profitable and every month is profitable. However, average daily profitability is only ~0.13% or annualized to about 30%. It is a lot of work for 30%? :(

I am mainly an options trader, so training to get better at trading butterflies is another one of my homework assignments. :(
 
Is making money in forex like getting into the moon? I saw many traders are not well satisfied with their trading result even after better market analysis. How do you think it?

If you have $5k account daytrading EuroFX Futures your notional value of capital is ~$1.1mil at 15-20%pa as a professional trader, there will be one or two people on this site that have experience of those numbers, the rest are trading leverage based on physical brokerage balance which the markets snack on.

It's why people say if you can trade X% per day or week or month you will become a billionaire, their inexperience discounts the fact that as capital increases you discount notional value of capital towards 1:1 with physical capital, very few can join the two points together, this is efficient-market hypothesis.
 
Thanks. Your homework assignment for paper trading is hard work!

So far, paper trades are net positive. I have about 9 months' statistics, daily, about 60% of scalps are winners, 3 out of 4 days are profitable and every month is profitable. However, average daily profitability is only ~0.13% or annualized to about 30%. It is a lot of work for 30%? :(

I am mainly an options trader, so training to get better at trading butterflies is another one of my homework assignments. :(
Hello ironchef,

Please do not feel bad, I was in SIM for 4 years trying to increase my skills.

Now I am an ES master trying to make a Million dollars within 3 years from now.

Follow @volpri and myself keep it simple. There is no other way but stare at the chart all day and click it.

For one week I took 500 trades for 2 months straight, trying to be the ES master and rich. Yes, my eyes and head was hurting everyday, but this is the only way if you want to be ES master and Rich. All other ways is a Lie.

Anyone that tell you there is another way to be the ES Master is a Liar.
 
Last edited:
Hello ironchef,

Please do not feel bad, I was in SIM for 4 years trying to increase my skills.

Now I am an ES master trying to make a Million dollars within 3 years from now.

Follow @volpri and myself keep it simple. There is no other way but stare at the chart all day and click it.

For one week I took 500 trades for 2 months straight, trying to be the ES master and rich. Yes, my eyes and head was hurting everyday, but this is the only way if you want to be ES master and Rich. All other ways is a Lie.

Anyone that tell you there is another way to be the ES Master is a Liar.
Thank you for the coaching.
 
Back
Top