Quote from ProfLogic:
First, you are trying to teach logic to retired logic teacher. You are in a no win situation.
Range Bar Charts - user defined price range (no user defined volume)
Constant Volume Bar Charts - user defined volume (no user defined price range)
Since these chart types, by sheer definition, are not the same your assessment of there sameness in regards to clarity is incorrect.
Adding noise was not the best choice of words to describe what I meant initially. Let me clarify by saying that, IMO, Range bars eliminate some clarity that pure price creates in its bar-by-bar movement for me. I can see where Range Bars could be a benefit for some that are more directional traders but I personally am meticulous on strict objective entries and exits. I know that "price break-outs" fail regularly from making HH's or LL's so logically to base bars on the same criteria should have the same or close consistency.