So you think a worldwide pandemic and complete shutdown of 75% of the earths population and world economies only merits a 3 week bear market?
After the “peak” illness hits its not like everything will return back to normal.
I think the 11 year bull has really really distorted what people expect from the stock market.
It’s not supposed to be free money.
You have to take some lumps along the way, and 3 weeks every 11 years isn’t enough.
The issue isn't whether these events are dramatic, unprecedented, historic etc - obviously they are, the issue is what's priced in vs. the way events are likely to actually unfold. It's just basic logic that however bad the hits to GDP, earnings and so on turn out to be, the market isn't going to tank another 30% if the news is "as bad as expected". Rather it would have to be meaningfully worse than expected, and at this point Q2 is already a cataclysmic writeoff.
The government has pretty much taken over the credit markets, and the banking system is solid, so there doesn't seem to be much chance of a bearish shock coming from there (at least for the time being). So, the bear case rests on lockdowns stretching into Q3 and/or people failing to resume "normal" behavior by late June, even after restrictions are formally lifted.
Possibly the lockdowns go on longer than expected, but once they end I think restaurants, service industries and so on will see business return to normal practically overnight, and indeed will see a surge of pent-up demand at the start. Personally we've already rescheduled travel plans that we were forced to cancel, to the July-September timeframe.