What is your edge?

Quote from billyjoerob:

Can we please stop pretending that "scalping" exists? Scalping used to refer to pit traders who would trade inside the bid and ask. Then it referred to daytraders playing volatile internet stocks, SOES bandits (whatever that is), etc. It doesn't exist anymore. If you've been scalping while the market went from 1550 to 666 and from 666 to 1360, then you've kind of missed out on two massive moves, not to mention the commodity bull market. And any current "scalper" is getting eaten alive by computers, which are much, much better at that sort of thing. So please stop pretending that you're a "scalper," unless that means you make $15 while trading 100 shares of NFLX. It doesn't exist any longer.

forex is a 24 hour market,there is nothing to stop any one from scalping on the bid and offer
 
Quote from oilfxpro:

This is because markets range 80 % of the time ,by using the probability that price will randomly fluctuate , many many more times closer to the current price for a longer period of time and give more opportunities/trades.A price is more likely to visit the same price many more times a day , within the daily range, it is less likely to trend/breakout on a daily basis.

Your edge is the ability to see the price action , feel the current market beat around the immediate price , feel the support /resistance and maybe foresee the direction . Imagine the land around you is flat , yet the world is round ,you can see the flat land but not the round world.On the smaller horizon , you can see clearer than the larger horizon.

I say randomly because most scalping is done on randomness, and most profitable scalping is done on probabilities (not trends).
There are traders scalping less profitably on intra day trends.

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?threadid=118599

The system you describe will fail due to randomness.
excellent post. this is spot on
 
Quote from billyjoerob:

You're talking about hundreds of a cent. Good luck with that.
you're kinda clueless it seems. Each TF is a fractal of another. Fx gives you leverage to employ any strategy you want on virtually any TF. Instead of arguing I think you should do some research into the subject you're talking about.
 
Quote from billyjoerob:

Can we please stop pretending that "scalping" exists? Scalping used to refer to pit traders who would trade inside the bid and ask. Then it referred to daytraders playing volatile internet stocks, SOES bandits (whatever that is), etc. It doesn't exist anymore. If you've been scalping while the market went from 1550 to 666 and from 666 to 1360, then you've kind of missed out on two massive moves, not to mention the commodity bull market. And any current "scalper" is getting eaten alive by computers, which are much, much better at that sort of thing. So please stop pretending that you're a "scalper," unless that means you make $15 while trading 100 shares of NFLX. It doesn't exist any longer.

B, you are wasting bandwidth, most will not listen to what you are saying, doesn't matter how right you are.

Now I will share my "edge". It is compound so there are different components.

1. Self discipline
2. Consistent 54% positive expectancy
3. 1.4-3.6 % account risk depending on trade
4. Use of expanded/flexible time frames to mitigate volatility
5. 3 "types" of trades taken, trend, range and range breakout
6. Vacation from, 2nd week of May to third week of Sept
7. At least 1.7:1 R R per trade

I think that is all I can share right now.

The Ever Wishing Everyone Good Trading VIPER
 
Quote from billyjoerob:

You're talking about hundreds of a cent. Good luck with that.

you guys are arguing about something that has been discussed so many times it pains me to have to read about it again
 
My edge, developing a trade matrix that is universal across all markets, able to detect price perturbations in a manner that can be acted upon quickly.

Any intrument, any timeframe.
 
Quote from ElectricSavant:

Perturbation theory: mathematical methods that give approximate solutions to problems that cannot be solved exactly

Nice work ES, I am impressed:)

In fact, you are the first person to identify that particular word as significant, again, bravo!
 
Quote from Davidee2: So what is your edge and how do you know that it works?


In my trading experience, losing more than $20,000.00 total over a course of 10+ years, conducting 6+ years of very difficult primary research to develop an unconventional technical analysis approach to the markets; in my opinion, there is not just one edge, but five (5) different edges.

To me, they are known as:

Money Management Model
Timing
Direction
Magnitude
Probability

Without the ability to execute on these five (5) giants, I would not be able to trade any market.

However, before one gets there, they have to do some preparatory work by asking themselves: Why trade? What's the point of trading? Can I do something else with my capital and my valuable time, that will yield a higher return, faster, other than trading?

Then, the individual has to put a price tag on the WHY they are trading. This is one of the first mental steps that most of the 95% who fail, never seem to get around to doing. This is because, most people don't really understand how their brain works. If people truly understood how their brain worked and how they really accomplished anything worthwhile in life, this would easily become their very first step in their trading career.

I can't tell you what your WHY value should be - nobody can. That value is defined by you and you alone. However, that value is extremely important to everything you do next. Your defined $WHY$ value, dictates everything else to follow - including precisely what type of trader you ultimately become. To underestimate the importance of the WHY question, is to not understand the process of becoming a long-term successful trader.

Then, you need to develop a Revenue Plan for reaching that value associated with the WHY you are in the business. This is the second biggest mistake that many of the 95% who fail seem to make - they haven't learned the difference between a Revenue Model and a Revenue Strategy, and why having both are critically important to long-term success. The Model is the WHY. The Strategy is the HOW. The rest of your entire Trading System, or Trading Methodology, which produces the Timing, Direction, Magnitude and Probability, should flow directly from this foundation.

Believe it or not, your Money Management Model, dictates the type and kind of trading indicators/signals/methods you build or develop going forward. It even governs the kind and type of trades you can and cannot execute. Everything you do in this business, begins with defining your $WHY$ and then building your Money Management Model. There is no more important first step to obtaining your "edges."

I can briefly discuss the rest later, if you are interested in learning.
 
Back
Top