What is Logical?

ARealGannTrader · Feb 11, 2009

Quote from MandelbrotSet:

Are you paying attention ARGT?

ProLogic does a lot more than "just use a momo indicator to verify higher highs and higher lows". He has his whole seminar courses/books thingy happening, via PM's to the ignorant noobs who fall for his cups of freely proffered koolaid.

BTW, did anyone every prove that his system actually works in real-timetrading?

Thought not.

My thing is that there really only one way to trade, higher highs and lows and vice versa. Where traders differ is that PL uses the ergodic to define trend. Others use RSI. I use angles. U may use a stochstic. At the end of the day we are trading a trend with respect to whatever time frame we are on.

Why the persecution?

If noobs get sucked in, all the better. We all gain, noobs gain experience, the rest of us gain profit. The markets will always work this way, you will always gain, either experience or profit.

I c a lot of threads of people chasing other people around saying, prove this or that.

What is that all about? Nobody owes nobody nothin. Take it, leave it. Noobs aint gonna listen anyway. They will take the same learning curve we all did.

Trading is like martial arts, get your azz kicked till you don't get your azz kicked. Next belt, add a contract.

Sushi · Feb 11, 2009

the issue here has nothing to do with the method. Although facts are NO ONE came forward saying the method actually works, is profligcmaster is a VENDOR. He should pay to market his wares regardless of if it works or not.

MandelbrotSet · Feb 11, 2009

Quote from ARealGannTrader:

My thing is that there really only one way to trade, higher highs and lows and vice versa.

Actually, that is not true.

Quote from ARealGannTrader:

Where traders differ is that PL uses the ergodic to define trend. Others use RSI. I use angles. U may use a stochstic. At the end of the day we are trading a trend with respect to whatever time frame we are on.

I don't use a stoch, but OK, point taken.

Quote from ARealGannTrader:

Why the persecution?

PoorProff is a stealth vendor sucking noobs in and charging tons of dough for books, seminars and related materials, capiche?

Quote from ARealGannTrader:

If noobs get sucked in, all the better. We all gain, noobs gain experience, the rest of us gain profit. The markets will always work this way, you will always gain, either experience or profit.

I c a lot of threads of people chasing other people around saying, prove this or that.

What is that all about? Nobody owes nobody nothin. Take it, leave it. Noobs aint gonna listen anyway. They will take the same learning curve we all did.

True

Quote from ARealGannTrader:

Trading is like martial arts, get your azz kicked till you don't get your azz kicked. Next belt, add a contract.

Now that's a great quote!

MandelbrotSet · Feb 11, 2009

Quote from ProfLogic:

Yup, we all prove it to ourselves as we trade it everyday. Sorry!:eek:

Now that's what I call solid proof! ... Not

MandelbrotSet · Feb 11, 2009

Ah, here's some testimony from one of ProfLogic's students:

Quote from Wi!s0n:

Sorry I just spilled my tea on my AppleMac, sure hope it comes back cause I was in the middle of a pm to someone when it crashed.

Anyway the labeling program is from the Prof and you just have to ask him for it. I was using Tradestation as they provide 6 months of historical tick data to build the volume bars. I noticed subtle differences between mine and the Prof's so, to eliminate any possible disadvantage altogether I subscribed to MC and eventually eSignal as well. I'm not sure it makes any appreciable difference, however as once you begin appreciating the rhythm of the fractals there is little difference between "perfect" and "near perfect" setups. I should add I am one of Bill's new students and therefore still learning.

Be sure to get in on their "PM Party" so you can get the lastest scoop with the auto label generator! ... ROTFLMAO

ProfLogic · Feb 11, 2009

Quote from MandelbrotSet:

Ah, here's some testimony from one of ProfLogic's students:

Be sure to get in on their "PM Party" so you can get the lastest scoop with the auto label generator! ... ROTFLMAO

Yup, its objective and free . . . and you have to be smarter than a 5th grader to use it so that leaves you out.

ProfLogic · Feb 11, 2009

Quote from Sushi:

the issue here has nothing to do with the method. Although facts are NO ONE came forward saying the method actually works, is profligcmaster is a VENDOR. He should pay to market his wares regardless of if it works or not.

Yes they did but you ignored them.
What I share is free . . . I have no clue how that translates in "fish" but free is free in English.

MandelbrotSet · Feb 14, 2009

Quote from ProfLogic:

Yes they did but you ignored them.
What I share is free . . . I have no clue how that translates in "fish" but free is free in English.

Yeah Right!

Here's an honest, unsolicited review of the good ProfLogic. :eek:

Thank you sir, thank you.

Quote from eurohunter:

I started with the prof years ago back when the main chart was a 777 tick chart.
I have been though all the changes he has made to his method from that point to now.

I made many friends in his chat room.

I have not talked to anyone that has ever made money with his method on a consistent day in day out basis day trading.

Now the focus is on swing and position trading. It is much easier to do this than day trade if you have the stomach for the large stops involved.

I made several changes to his method before I started making regular profits day trading.

His method is logical and there in is the problem many face. It sounds perfect why cant I make it work.

Before paying $8000 for a course I would ask to see trading statements from those that use the method.

ProfLogic · Feb 15, 2009

Quote from MandelbrotSet:

Yeah Right!

Here's an honest, unsolicited review of the good ProfLogic. :eek:

Thank you sir, thank you.

Another completely fabricated post by a pathalogical liar. The street has taught you well Jimmy Jam.

MandelbrotSet · Feb 15, 2009

Quote from ProfLogic:

Another completely fabricated post by a pathalogical liar. The street has taught you well Jimmy Jam.

To the contrary:

I didn't makeup that user ID, and I didn't make that post. It's the truth as presented by someone who has had experience with you and your "perfect" system.

LOL