What Backtesting Platform do you use?
- Thread starter Baron
- Start date
very satisfied with Tradestation 8, hardly not too long to pick
the language and now trying to learn some C++ coding
required to use for EL extension sdk. I prefer it over the
wealthlab in many areas, and did extensive research before
going with Tradestation. Also i found Wealthscript very
similar to easylanguage, no difficulty to shift if i need to,
But EL is better documented and offers more functions
Never touched Qunatdeveloper, Do you need to be be
fluent in C++ in order to use it?
Also any better read-made framework than quantdeveloper
in market with subscription and open source code?
This appears to be a good place to ask this question! I am looking to upgrade my trading analysis software and am trying to be thorough in my 'due diligence' before I commit to buying a software package.
Currently, I use TS 4.0 because it is and has been stable, but there are many things that it is unable to do.
I am looking for a package that can be used to test a system across a basket of markets (could be a couple of markets to as many as 50) and then optimizing the system on the basket. I know that there are analysis packages out there that claim to be able to accomplish this. Can they really do what they advertize and what hoops must be jumped through to perform the testing and at what cost?
Thanks
Currently, I use TS 4.0 because it is and has been stable, but there are many things that it is unable to do.
I am looking for a package that can be used to test a system across a basket of markets (could be a couple of markets to as many as 50) and then optimizing the system on the basket. I know that there are analysis packages out there that claim to be able to accomplish this. Can they really do what they advertize and what hoops must be jumped through to perform the testing and at what cost?
Thanks
I mainly use my own home grown platform that I developed. Itâs features include a variety of data mining tools, GA optimization, customized optimization objective functions, automatic in-sample/out-ofâsample testing with statistical analysis, portfolio optimization (optimize parameter across issues or separately), portfolio position sizing, and a number of other features that I experiment with (e.g., fuzzy logic, neurofuzzy networks, etc.)
Because all my strategies are compiled into binary executables (not interpreted as is done most commercial platforms) my backtesting runs at least 10 times faster (not to mention the benefits of GA optimization).
I also use TradeStation and NeuroShell DayTrader.
Because all my strategies are compiled into binary executables (not interpreted as is done most commercial platforms) my backtesting runs at least 10 times faster (not to mention the benefits of GA optimization).
I also use TradeStation and NeuroShell DayTrader.
Murray Ruggiero
Sponsor
When I designed TradersStudio I design it to make the portfolio level testing as easy to use as possible. Here is a link to a free tutorial on TradersStudio.com
http://www.tradersstudio.com/Default.aspx?tabid=81
This shows you how to test a simple system on a basket of markets. When running a system you can look at the consolidated results across all the markets or any individual market with just one mouse click.
When dealing with optimization across a portfolio for a given system TradersStudio has no equal. First you don't have to make any changes to your system to do an optimization, the same version you run to get your trades is the same you optimize. This means that you can optimize even black box systems, if they allow you to set your own parameters.
Our metaphor for optimization is the same as TradeStation, except that we work at the portfolio level and TradeStation does not. You simply select optimize and set a start,stop and step parameters for each parameter the system has.
TradersStudio allows you to optimize a system on a basket of one to as many as hundreds of markets. Finally the same optimization produces both portfolio level results as well as the results on each individual market. You can view any combination of these you want with just one mouse click. This would allow you to pick the best set of parameters with one of your criteriaâs being tradable on at least one meat for example without having to rerun you results.
Please take the time to view this tutorial; I am sure you will find it informative. I hope other vendors or customers of other products will discuss the steps involved in portfolio level testing in their product. If you have questions feel free to ask.
http://www.tradersstudio.com/Default.aspx?tabid=81
This shows you how to test a simple system on a basket of markets. When running a system you can look at the consolidated results across all the markets or any individual market with just one mouse click.
When dealing with optimization across a portfolio for a given system TradersStudio has no equal. First you don't have to make any changes to your system to do an optimization, the same version you run to get your trades is the same you optimize. This means that you can optimize even black box systems, if they allow you to set your own parameters.
Our metaphor for optimization is the same as TradeStation, except that we work at the portfolio level and TradeStation does not. You simply select optimize and set a start,stop and step parameters for each parameter the system has.
TradersStudio allows you to optimize a system on a basket of one to as many as hundreds of markets. Finally the same optimization produces both portfolio level results as well as the results on each individual market. You can view any combination of these you want with just one mouse click. This would allow you to pick the best set of parameters with one of your criteriaâs being tradable on at least one meat for example without having to rerun you results.
Please take the time to view this tutorial; I am sure you will find it informative. I hope other vendors or customers of other products will discuss the steps involved in portfolio level testing in their product. If you have questions feel free to ask.
Murray Ruggiero
Sponsor
Yes give me the big list, we can have 100 pages of entries in this thread
Did you buy the license or are you on the monthly scheme?
In comparing trading platforms, I have found that TradersStudio is $499 and AmiBroker is $229. On their website, AmiBroker claims to do much the same thing as TradersStudio. Why is it so much less?
The earlier thread by MR mentioned that some platforms require system alteration to perform portfolio level optimization. Can someone tell me which platforms require special coding (if any)?
I watched the video on the TradersStudio website as mentioned in the earlier thread and it appeared that portfolio optimization is as simple as described. Basically, it is point and click.
Can someone give me an idea how to optimize a system in Amibroker on a basket of markets? I have looked at their website and was fairly impressed with the content, but was left wondering what steps were necessary to actually make the program do optimization at the portfolio level.
Thanks
The earlier thread by MR mentioned that some platforms require system alteration to perform portfolio level optimization. Can someone tell me which platforms require special coding (if any)?
I watched the video on the TradersStudio website as mentioned in the earlier thread and it appeared that portfolio optimization is as simple as described. Basically, it is point and click.
Can someone give me an idea how to optimize a system in Amibroker on a basket of markets? I have looked at their website and was fairly impressed with the content, but was left wondering what steps were necessary to actually make the program do optimization at the portfolio level.
Thanks
Investor RT. www.linnsoft.com Very fast and full featured.