Alright, good. The Cato report was a good read. It places the false positive number quite a bit lower than you suggested but - whatever- it laid the issues out in an organized way.
Roughly 0.15 percent of all E-Verify queries result in a false “final non-confirmation.”
Looks like there is even a greater problem too with ineligibles coming back as eligible. People shovel a bunch of false documentation into the system but once they are branded as eligible, e-verify then becomes their go-to friend for the rest of their life.
Be interesting to see how it goes in the states that are starting to link the photo from the dmv over to the database.
Part of this dilemma is that both the conservatives and the liberals oppose a national identity card which would put an end to a lot of this bullshit. The conservatives don't want it- not all, some are 100% in favor- because it is allegedly a Big Brother thing. But then they end out supporting all this incremental big brother database stuff in the background which attempts to accomplish the same thing. The libs of course oppose it because lots of their folks are illegals and they would not qualify for a national identity card.
Full disclosure: I am 110% in favor of a national identity card. And yes I know what libertarians say about that but if I want a friend, I will get a dog.
The system has been improving and my friend assures me that it is worse that that in his experience but variance is expected on state and demographic. He gave me the 2% figure, perhaps that was 2014 or initial error. Still 180k+ legit citizens a year having their lived possibly ruined is not ok, not just a few broken eggs.
Yes, the principle of no mandatory single identity cards is shared with the UK, Ireland, OZ, NZ etc. All are drifting in the direction of mandatory ID, a European Napoleonic system where the individual citizen is below the state. Guilty until proven innocent etc. The subtleties are beyond the education and intellect/interest of the average person in modern days so used to privacy being treated loosely online.
Be careful what you give up without understanding how it will be in 30 years but that does not mean change does not have to happen with exponential population growth.
My experience of living in US, UK, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand has been the USA has the worst legal system & cops, Australia next and the remaining, pretty ok & respectful. I would hate to have UK cops being the bossy assholes I've seen in the US and Oz (not as bad). Scale may play a part in the psychology, Australia is the size of the continental USA.
Other's experience will be different.
Last edited:
would not expect to be treated with respect by authority or have the guts to do more than look at your feet. You rationalise being lorded over and shaken down as a good thing. If I was born in the US, I'd be in the similar situation I guess.