Troubles with Scottrade..

Quote from hughb:

:confused:

I just call them and have a check sent out.

same here.

btw i use Scottrade for swing/long term trades and have never had any issues. I've made a few day trades for fun and got bad fills if i didn't use limit orders.
 
You guys are making my point.

Given a choice, wouldn't you rather just transfer cash back into your bank account, as opposed to calling scottrade, waiting for a check to show and then having to deposit that check?
 
Quote from trader_david:

I understood your problems since I was once with Scottrade, now I have no business with them. as a veteran sctttrader, I would say Scottrade is the worst firm. they cheated you on Elite trading platform: did you carefully check their execution log in your Elite trading platform you will find the execution is actually back-filled (that means after the fact filling, they are front running you). I once caught them off guard, they inserted a loser position into my account ( I once put out an order and then cancelled), and insisted I should eat the bullet, then I submitted my video ( I was trading), they have nothing to say, then suddenly the position disspeared, what a fucking firm!

plus their rate is too expensive

I experienced the similar problems as you described: cancel an order, then no confirmation, then you can not cancel it... many many ...

but I would say: the color of sparrows in the whole wild world is black.

I am currently with IB, but I noticed TWS is very frustrating too, not reliable/chart bar removal/data feeding problem, I am planning to buy some data feeding fro other firms in case IB does some tricks to me and I can get my money back even there is account contract!

These dishonest brokers are one of the reasons why a trader spent so much time in the dark searching for the light at the end of the tunnel.

Looking back, I am totally disgusted at the way Scottrade treated me: front-running constantly. On many occasions, I sent market orders and didn't see any execution for minutes, and I couldn't cancel the market orders. In the meantime, Scottrade data and chart were completely lagging in a fast-moving market.

If you are losing money, check if you have a bad broker first. You don't want to blame the market for your losses, but the market presented to you is the one brought to your computer screen by your broker. If your broker brought to you a crooked market, yes, you can blame the "market." It's the broker's "market," not the real market.
 
Quote from NazSpaz:

Great link! Clicked through on NASD site and then it also says this:

"Scottrade, Inc. may receive payment from Knight Capital
Markets LLC (Trimark), a subsidiary of Knight Trading
Group, Inc., for orders in listed stocks. Payment is
variable based on order and execution types. Payments
during second quarter 2008 averaged at or below $0.001
per share.

Scottrade's principal shareholder and President is a
director and shareholder of Knight Trading Group, Inc."


Wow, that's some serious conflict of interest.

GUESS WHO KNIGHT TRADING IS????????????????

SCOTTRADE IS OWNED BY KNIGHT TRADING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

IN OTHERWORDS THEY ARE SELLING YOU STOCK FROM THEIR OWN STOCK POOL!

WHEN I FIGURED OUT WHAT THEY WERE DOING I CLOSED MY ACCOUNT WITH THEM WHILE I STILL HAD SOME MONEY LEFT=HALF OUR ORIGINAL ACCOUNT AMOUNT!

IT WAS A TRADE WITH APPLE THAT BROKE THE CAMELS BACK
APPLE HAD BEEN WAFFLING AROUND ALL DAY LONG AROUND 139.-IT WAS ACTING GOOFY SHOWING SOME WEAKNESS AND THE MARKET MAKERS WERE NOT LETTING IT GO ANYWHERE-SO THEY LET IT DROP AND BREAK THRU A LOT PEOPLES STOPS ALL THE TO 133. IN A MATTER OF A MINUTE AND A HALF-I PLACED A MARKET ORDER-NOT EVEN A LIMIT ORDER AT THE OR NEAR THE BOTTOM OF THE PLUNGE-ORDER NEVER FILLED-SCOTTRADE WOULD NOT HONOR THE TRADE EVEN THOUGH I HAD SCREEN SHOT SHOWING I WAS CONNECTED AND THAT I REALLY HAD PLACED THE ORDER-I HAD A 10 MEG STREAM FROM COMCAST FOR MY CONNECTION-SCOTTRADE SAID MY SERVICE WAS INTERUPTED DURING THE TRADE,THAT IS WHY THEY NEVER RECIEVED IT AT THEIR ORDER DESK-COMCAST VERIFIED NO SUCH THING OCCURRED!
SCOTTRADE WOULD NOT HONOR MY TRADE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
EVEN AFTER THREATENING TO LEAVE THEM-THEY HAD MADE A LOT OF MONEY OFF OF US IN 5 MONTHS-WE TRADED 7 MILLION DOLLARS WORTH OF STOCK IN 5 MONTHS-MOST STOCKS WERE UNDER $15.00 A SHARE!
ANYWHO
I FIGURED OUT THEY COULD NOT SELL ME STOCK FROM THEIR HOLDINGS BECAUSE THEY PAID MORE THAN I DID FOR IT-AND THEY NEVER ROUTED MY ORDER TO THE EXCHANGE!
THAT TRADE WOULD HAVE GROSSED ME 6-12 GRAND,THE WAY THE STOCK MOVED OVER THE NEXT DAY-I WAITED FOR A WEEK TOO MAKE THAT TRADE!
I WAS NOT ONE OF THOSE TRADERS WHO LEFT HIS DESK-I WORKED A FULL SHIFT AN HOUR BEFORE MKT OPEN AND SOMETIMES AFTER HOURS TRADING
ANYWHO THAT CHAPPED MY HIDE AND I SAID I WAS DONE TRADING WITH SCOTTRADE AFTER THAT HAPPPENED-SHAME ON THEM-AND THAT WAS NOT THE FIRST TIME I SCREWED BY THEM-BUT IT WAS THE LAST!:mad:
 
Scottrade is spending its money on TV commercials instead of making a better platform!

May be its software work has been outsourced faraway.
 
Quote from hottpotat0:

GUESS WHO KNIGHT TRADING IS????????????????

SCOTTRADE IS OWNED BY KNIGHT TRADING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

IN OTHERWORDS THEY ARE SELLING YOU STOCK FROM THEIR OWN STOCK POOL!

WHEN I FIGURED OUT WHAT THEY WERE DOING I CLOSED MY ACCOUNT WITH THEM WHILE I STILL HAD SOME MONEY LEFT=HALF OUR ORIGINAL ACCOUNT AMOUNT!

IT WAS A TRADE WITH APPLE THAT BROKE THE CAMELS BACK
APPLE HAD BEEN WAFFLING AROUND ALL DAY LONG AROUND 139.-IT WAS ACTING GOOFY SHOWING SOME WEAKNESS AND THE MARKET MAKERS WERE NOT LETTING IT GO ANYWHERE-SO THEY LET IT DROP AND BREAK THRU A LOT PEOPLES STOPS ALL THE TO 133. IN A MATTER OF A MINUTE AND A HALF-I PLACED A MARKET ORDER-NOT EVEN A LIMIT ORDER AT THE OR NEAR THE BOTTOM OF THE PLUNGE-ORDER NEVER FILLED-SCOTTRADE WOULD NOT HONOR THE TRADE EVEN THOUGH I HAD SCREEN SHOT SHOWING I WAS CONNECTED AND THAT I REALLY HAD PLACED THE ORDER-I HAD A 10 MEG STREAM FROM COMCAST FOR MY CONNECTION-SCOTTRADE SAID MY SERVICE WAS INTERUPTED DURING THE TRADE,THAT IS WHY THEY NEVER RECIEVED IT AT THEIR ORDER DESK-COMCAST VERIFIED NO SUCH THING OCCURRED!
SCOTTRADE WOULD NOT HONOR MY TRADE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
EVEN AFTER THREATENING TO LEAVE THEM-THEY HAD MADE A LOT OF MONEY OFF OF US IN 5 MONTHS-WE TRADED 7 MILLION DOLLARS WORTH OF STOCK IN 5 MONTHS-MOST STOCKS WERE UNDER $15.00 A SHARE!
ANYWHO
I FIGURED OUT THEY COULD NOT SELL ME STOCK FROM THEIR HOLDINGS BECAUSE THEY PAID MORE THAN I DID FOR IT-AND THEY NEVER ROUTED MY ORDER TO THE EXCHANGE!
THAT TRADE WOULD HAVE GROSSED ME 6-12 GRAND,THE WAY THE STOCK MOVED OVER THE NEXT DAY-I WAITED FOR A WEEK TOO MAKE THAT TRADE!
I WAS NOT ONE OF THOSE TRADERS WHO LEFT HIS DESK-I WORKED A FULL SHIFT AN HOUR BEFORE MKT OPEN AND SOMETIMES AFTER HOURS TRADING
ANYWHO THAT CHAPPED MY HIDE AND I SAID I WAS DONE TRADING WITH SCOTTRADE AFTER THAT HAPPPENED-SHAME ON THEM-AND THAT WAS NOT THE FIRST TIME I SCREWED BY THEM-BUT IT WAS THE LAST!:mad:

Most day traders lost money because of dishonest brokers and other kinds of thieves.

Trading is a relatively simple task, what makes it difficult for a retail day trader to make money is those sharks that prey on innocent traders.
 
Back
Top