Quote from trader_david:
I understood your problems since I was once with Scottrade, now I have no business with them. as a veteran sctttrader, I would say Scottrade is the worst firm. they cheated you on Elite trading platform: did you carefully check their execution log in your Elite trading platform you will find the execution is actually back-filled (that means after the fact filling, they are front running you). I once caught them off guard, they inserted a loser position into my account ( I once put out an order and then cancelled), and insisted I should eat the bullet, then I submitted my video ( I was trading), they have nothing to say, then suddenly the position disspeared, what a fucking firm!
plus their rate is too expensive
I experienced the similar problems as you described: cancel an order, then no confirmation, then you can not cancel it... many many ...
but I would say: the color of sparrows in the whole wild world is black.
I am currently with IB, but I noticed TWS is very frustrating too, not reliable/chart bar removal/data feeding problem, I am planning to buy some data feeding fro other firms in case IB does some tricks to me and I can get my money back even there is account contract!
Quote from NazSpaz:
Great link! Clicked through on NASD site and then it also says this:
"Scottrade, Inc. may receive payment from Knight Capital
Markets LLC (Trimark), a subsidiary of Knight Trading
Group, Inc., for orders in listed stocks. Payment is
variable based on order and execution types. Payments
during second quarter 2008 averaged at or below $0.001
per share.
Scottrade's principal shareholder and President is a
director and shareholder of Knight Trading Group, Inc."
Wow, that's some serious conflict of interest.

Quote from hottpotat0:
GUESS WHO KNIGHT TRADING IS????????????????
SCOTTRADE IS OWNED BY KNIGHT TRADING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
IN OTHERWORDS THEY ARE SELLING YOU STOCK FROM THEIR OWN STOCK POOL!
WHEN I FIGURED OUT WHAT THEY WERE DOING I CLOSED MY ACCOUNT WITH THEM WHILE I STILL HAD SOME MONEY LEFT=HALF OUR ORIGINAL ACCOUNT AMOUNT!
IT WAS A TRADE WITH APPLE THAT BROKE THE CAMELS BACK
APPLE HAD BEEN WAFFLING AROUND ALL DAY LONG AROUND 139.-IT WAS ACTING GOOFY SHOWING SOME WEAKNESS AND THE MARKET MAKERS WERE NOT LETTING IT GO ANYWHERE-SO THEY LET IT DROP AND BREAK THRU A LOT PEOPLES STOPS ALL THE TO 133. IN A MATTER OF A MINUTE AND A HALF-I PLACED A MARKET ORDER-NOT EVEN A LIMIT ORDER AT THE OR NEAR THE BOTTOM OF THE PLUNGE-ORDER NEVER FILLED-SCOTTRADE WOULD NOT HONOR THE TRADE EVEN THOUGH I HAD SCREEN SHOT SHOWING I WAS CONNECTED AND THAT I REALLY HAD PLACED THE ORDER-I HAD A 10 MEG STREAM FROM COMCAST FOR MY CONNECTION-SCOTTRADE SAID MY SERVICE WAS INTERUPTED DURING THE TRADE,THAT IS WHY THEY NEVER RECIEVED IT AT THEIR ORDER DESK-COMCAST VERIFIED NO SUCH THING OCCURRED!
SCOTTRADE WOULD NOT HONOR MY TRADE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
EVEN AFTER THREATENING TO LEAVE THEM-THEY HAD MADE A LOT OF MONEY OFF OF US IN 5 MONTHS-WE TRADED 7 MILLION DOLLARS WORTH OF STOCK IN 5 MONTHS-MOST STOCKS WERE UNDER $15.00 A SHARE!
ANYWHO
I FIGURED OUT THEY COULD NOT SELL ME STOCK FROM THEIR HOLDINGS BECAUSE THEY PAID MORE THAN I DID FOR IT-AND THEY NEVER ROUTED MY ORDER TO THE EXCHANGE!
THAT TRADE WOULD HAVE GROSSED ME 6-12 GRAND,THE WAY THE STOCK MOVED OVER THE NEXT DAY-I WAITED FOR A WEEK TOO MAKE THAT TRADE!
I WAS NOT ONE OF THOSE TRADERS WHO LEFT HIS DESK-I WORKED A FULL SHIFT AN HOUR BEFORE MKT OPEN AND SOMETIMES AFTER HOURS TRADING
ANYWHO THAT CHAPPED MY HIDE AND I SAID I WAS DONE TRADING WITH SCOTTRADE AFTER THAT HAPPPENED-SHAME ON THEM-AND THAT WAS NOT THE FIRST TIME I SCREWED BY THEM-BUT IT WAS THE LAST!![]()