I`ve read the first couple pages of this thread & can say that the ES is a different animal these days & not really conducive for tick scalping/super short term, as there is no more getting filled on the bid/ask, so one is down a solid 2 ticks right off the get go.
That said, I`ve been trading ES since `99... I`d established a daily target of
1K - 1500 a day for what I called my blue collar account & was able to consistently win 15-18 days out of a 20-22 day a month account... 2 trades a day max.. morning set up & afternoon set up like clock work, it was a close to automated without being automated as one can get.
So it is possible but, imho, you would have to open up your time frame a bit in order to make a real living. It takes balls to put your trades out there & leave yourself open to criticism from the arm chair experts... Good Luck & refine your craft.