I enjoy reading your journal, and I'm doing it so that I tweak my own bias. But this bias in me says that when shit hits the fan economically, most of this "digital" stuff will tank.
The value in NFTs won't exist when free money stops flowing. The value of a digital world will be non existent when it becomes difficult to live in the real world (ie. food price inflation, difficulty paying for housing, riots leading to a lack of safety.) All this stuff about owning "property" in some digital metaverse can evaporate in a microsecond. It won't have value when you're struggling in the real world.
And although crypto will be around, with BTC being so archaic, and in direct competition with what the governments will offer, might fall to the way side, even if it does have another stellar rally. Basically, if the government losses control over the monetary system because it goes decentralized, and some universal coin is the leader, then the government pretty much looses the ability to control the population and provide services. When you have no stability or services, you have no functioning digital world. All you need is some jackass to drive his truck into a cellphone tower to knock out your link to the digital world.
So in essence, the continued move to everything digital relies on global stability, and that stability I see eroding going forward. Look at how much has changed in Afghanistan in just one week.
Thanks for reading!
Let me address each of the points
- "The value in NFTs won't exist when free money stops flowing". People raised a similar point about US tech stocks, yet Janet Yellen raised rates by 225 bps a few years ago, and nothing much happened. You had the normal fluctuations you had in stocks (up or down 20%). This time around, it is evern worse because debt to gdp ratios are even higher so most likely they wont be able to raise rates by much and at any slowdown they will cut it again. 0% rates (financial repression) will be with us for a long-time because it helps the economy delever (Its part of the beautiful deleveraging that Dalio talks about)
-"It won't have value when you're struggling in the real world.". Sure, if there is a depression (which it is what you seem to be alluding to), a lot of this stuff will have a liquidity crunch. But what wont? Stocks will implode, corporate bonds will look suspect, cash will be king and maybe gold. But a depression (in the US) is off the table because they will ALWAYS choose to print tons of cash rather than to let one happen. They learned the lessons from the 30's, they applied in 2008, they applied it again in Covid. So while crypto might sell-off initially when big market disllocations hit, eventually it will rise again when the money printer is opened again. Like it happened in Covid. The supposed correlation between crypto and stocks is actually one of the bull points, because US stocks aren't exactly cheap (they are late in their cycle) but crypto is early in its cycle and it benefits from the money printer just as much
-"Basically, if the government losses control over the monetary system because it goes decentralized, and some universal coin is the leader, then the government pretty much looses the ability to control the population and provide services". Sure, these digital stores of value might create a problem for governments because people will rather own them rather than bonds, so at some point, it could hurt governments ability to finance themselves. But that is much too early to be worried about that and the same point can be made against the owning of Gold, Art, rare coins, stamps, wine collections etc etc. The point basically is "its not worth to own assets that can't be devalued, because the government wont let you, so let them devalue you". I think that is a mistake because the risk can be managed along the way. Furthermore in that 70's and early 80's, there was no ban on the ownership of hard assets even though they were super popular due to inflation. Heck, in the UK, there was no ban (to my knowledge) and they had to be bailed out by the IMF!
So, its like Raoul Pal says "talk to me when this stuff is at $10T and then we will see if they ban it"