Level 2 traverse trading continues as Beginner trading becomes a traderâs history. Intermediate trading contrasts with beginner trading in that âanticipationâ becomes part of the inference of the traderâs perception. Because I could not get across what boot camp is in the first four weeks of the month of boot camp, I missed to opportunity to comment to recruits on how the drilling interaction relates to the Present and how âanticipationâ works in the mind.
Here you see the four columns of Volume are duplicated and applied to YM as well as ES. Similarly, the three columns of Price are duplicated for and applied for YM price. These 14 columns are all interrelated and the frequency of MADA is such that for the first time a lot of âmental carryoverâ begins to occur. Usually I can get at this sooner but the boot camp didnât pan out in terms of work and working frequency. If anyone does this level of logging, they will see what I mean and log notes and AHAâs on the backs of prior pages in the 4 daily log pages. This is where âyou know that you knowâ really hits hard and makes it possible to be both relaxed and highly focused on carving turns. Most of the âprematureâ and âlaggingâ habits get automatic and personal attention by this time. As a note, in PA trading, by the time this much experience has been put in, bad habits get exacerbated instead. The âyou pick your own exitsâ is the easiest quotable simple symptom.
The focus of two merged YM and ES markets where one is less differentiated (30 vs 500) allows a ânaturalâ differentiation to begin in the mind. You shall begin to see the âequivalenceâ of exit followed by entry in the opposite direction.
Posting and interaction follow the same many parts of the day. Again an improvement in reversals is occurring and it is recognizable that there ânever was any rushâ in doing a reversal. In this log we pass over the âkneeâ of the learning surve and the added capability in annotating and logging and critical thinking is very notable. Everything is a âbreeze and SOP; there are never, any more any surprises in making money and there is a strong recognition of how the market migrate and never jump around. A partnership that is recognizable has been formed.
Quote from jack hershey:
Spikes
In intermediate we have YM telegraphing to the ES and the ends of bars that are extending the range or trand or traverse are important.
The end of the bar, where it is in annotating and where it is in the movement of a profit segment, is a TELL from the market to you for your data cluster and on to the A D and A of MADA.
Efficiency is the topic.
As a bar ends (or, latter in skills, in intrabar occurance occurs) it may reach its maximum volatility and the related volume is ending a surge on PRV, then you are haviing a first chance. In trading there are first and second chances given you. In between these you need to bear down as see that the first chance came and went. The first chance is over and you are anticipating the second chance coming up.
Presently, in boot camp both chances are just simply missed. effective means trading confirmed traverses after the end of a given traverse.
The first chance ends as price retreats two or more tics into the close of the bar.
The par of the bar from the end back to the close is the "spike" or lightening rod type apprearance of the end of the bar.
By recognizing the price movement into the end and back a tic, you look at the dynamic of the volume and see that volume confirms that the price is going to receed further.
Lets call the above "awakening to spikes".
You have awakened and now we turn to making money (batting).
We step back and reason critically to understand that SCT uses sequences and we talk in scientific terms about price and volume.
A bar is advancing the trend of the level under view. Relative increases in volume are used to advance price momentarily. This brief volume surge coming and going is volume accelerating then decelerating. Later, we see it all quite nicely in four concurrent other places. For now, we use the "awakening" narrative going forward in time and step back the "before" the spike began and use our senses to get the whole sequence down from pre spike to spike.
Two pre spike things: steady volume transition (dom or non dom), then a brief volume surge begining near the end of the bar (we now have YM, then ES doing this in stereo, as well).
The surge beginning takes us to the end of the price extension, we hit T when the volume surge extinguishes and the volume goes into an underdamped state to return to the pre existing volume transition of dom or non dom.
This was the (first chance.) The second chance is the C to O of the bars and the following extreme value of the second bar. After that it is an IBGS.
In this case on 17NOV08 we have a point 1 of a short traverse at the spike..
I have been harboring a belief that quite possibly the only way to learn the methodology is by doing the drills (learning to monitor). This belief of mine has been growing stronger and stronger after I was able to achieve some notable progress following the regimen of unbiased annotation practice.Quote from Neoxx:
... Jack repeatedly advocated perceptual and experiential learning, and asserted that knowledge is not gained by reading, reading ANYTHING...
For a beginner, who makes decisions at the end of bar, IMO it makes no difference whether a static or dynamic chart is practiced on. But a real time monitoring is obviously a must for next step. So, since people often do things without knowing it - people are actually know much more then they think they do. The sequences, which develops inside 5 min bar certainly register in the unconscious even if not noticed consciously.Quote from Neoxx:
Thanks for the insightful comments, Romanus.
To expand, I think we're dealing with a dynamic kind of pattern recognition, seeing things unfold, which is why Jack stresses the importance of real-time monitoring and references the three operators (spatial, movement and shape).
He also mentions seeing and hearing the market's TELLS, and describes four adjuncts which facilitate this (largely unconscious) process: price annotations, volume annotations, the platform and the log.
So in effect, while the absence of a log or the lack of comprehensive annotation may not seem harmful, by dramatically reducing the unconscious uptake of information, they may retard the entire process.
... I guess what you two are saying leads to the conclusion that too much annotating automation might be counterproductive, as it short circuits the pattern recognition brain training ... automation inherently filters out price and volume nuances ... anyway, there is an analysis part of this method that's more than just pattern recognition, and that can't be successfully done without the good understanding of the PV principle ...Quote from romanus & neoxx:
...
