Surf's Special Situation Journal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote from marketsurfer:

No, it's been proven that fixed stops actually degrade a systems performance. The key is position sizing and hedging-- stops are a creation of the market machine that profits fom your trading. surf
And what is the nature of your hedging that doesn't "profit the market machine?"
 
Quote from Brass:

And what is the nature of your hedging that doesn't "profit the market machine?"

obviously, everything feeds the machine- our goal is make sure we feed it as little as possible----proper hedging aligned with position sizing simply decreases the costs--this is why all the forex dealers push stops heavily as they actually increase losses over the long run--- these devious folks also push TA for the same reasons-- their wins are your losses--- very naive not to understand market 101.
 
Quote from marketsurfer:

obviously, everything feeds the machine- --proper hedging aligned with position sizing simply decreases the costs--this is why all the forex dealers push stops heavily as they actually increase losses over the long run--- these devious folks also push TA for the same reasons-- their wins are your losses--- very naive not to understand market 101.
Okay, but you still haven't generally defined the nature of your hedging. And how does "proper" hedging decrease overall costs (of transactions and bad calls) better than "proper" stop placement?
 
Quote from marketsurfer:

Dozens of places,

one cannot use the same (say, $1.00) stop for each trade but each trade can have it's own stop based on the price and volatility currently happening. i agree, a fixed stop regardless of anything else is dumb.
 
Quote from Brass:

Okay, but you still haven't generally defined the nature of your hedging.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you think surf is long the JCP competitor? To hedge?
For example one is Macy's.
Hmm, but really he will lose all the profit of his long hedge if he stay in the bad trade of short JCP too long in time.

Surf, do you want to talk about your hedging? Or is that secret?:eek: :)
 
Quote from trendlover:

Quote from Brass:

Okay, but you still haven't generally defined the nature of your hedging.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you think surf is long the JCP competitor? To hedge?
For example one is Macy's.
Hmm, but really he will lose all the profit of his long hedge if he stay in the bad trade of short JCP too long in time.

Surf, do you want to talk about your hedging? Or is that secret?:eek: :)
I have no idea. I'm not even concerned with the specifics of surf's hedging. I'm only interested in the most basic of generalities so that he can explain how "proper" hedging decreases overall costs (of transactions and bad calls) better than "proper" stop placement?
 
Quote from Brass:

I have no idea. I'm not even concerned with the specifics of surf's hedging. I'm only interested in the most basic of generalities so that he can explain how "proper" hedging is superior to "proper" stop placement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ok yes. (If) surf have put stop loss for his short JCP (when he place his short bet), than he will have more profit on his long bet of the competitor hedge (If that is his strategy hedge).

Surf is saying (position size). So I guess if he lose all his money on the JCP short, he really do not care because he only make the small bet of money in compared to % of all his trading money. I am guessing. I really do not understand the game like you do. I like to read and watch!
 
Quote from TRS:

Surf can't trade.

Never understood the game.....

maybe this time will be different? or maybe not. not a good start, that's for sure. but it's still early.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top