Spydertrader's Jack Hershey Futures Trading Journal

Status
Not open for further replies.
TraderD72 I appreciate you're respons very much.

>most importantly, wait for volume (or PRV) to be above the >previous Volume bar

I will focus more on this starting today.

It's just that sometimes point3 comes after 5 minutes (which is quick) and sometimes after 30 minutes.

That having said, volume does give the clue and the point 3 almost always comes later than I expect.

regards,
Ivo


Quote from TraderD72:

This has been my focus this entire past week. (review some of my prior posts)

I was often identifying my point 3 area too soon.

psychologically I didn't ant to miss the move but on the flip side I was uneasy with price moving against my entry area too much.

As a consequence price would then move against me by a few ticks or points.

After reviewing numerous charts I concluded that most of my emphasis was on the price bars themselves instead of a "complete data set" (price, volume, context, etc).

For example, at the start of an UP TREND, I would see the non dominant traverse and I would eagerly await the arrival of my point 3 area. Then the first GREEN bar I would see I would often mark this as my point 3 when it broke the "tape".

Next thing I knew price would move stall and move sideways or, even worse, it would move down a few ticks or points. I would then think I was wrong and say to myself that if I was in this position I would look to exit.

Then, of course, we put in the "real" point 3 and head straight up.

So now I not only wait for the tape to break but ,most importantly, wait for volume (or PRV) to be above the previous Volume bar and price (most times) to break the previous price bar high/low. ( this sounds SO basic but I wasnt doing it)

On the times that I did enter early this past week if price would stall I would immediately look to volume.

If it was going sideways or slightly against me on LOW VOLUME I was MUCH more confident in "fanning out" my channel as opposed to thinking EXIT.

I also realized that often times the PRICE BAR we mark as a point 3 is NOT neccesailly the price bar we would use to enter a position.

The price point could have established a higher low (in a UP channel) ,so to speak, but the volume has yet to arrive to drive price in the dominant direction.


Whew! Sorry for the long post but I was very frustrated with point 3's identification as well so I hope this helps in some small way.

As always comments or correction is welcome!
 
Quote from TraderD72:

This has been my focus this entire past week. (review some of my prior posts)

I was often identifying my point 3 area too soon.

psychologically I didn't want to miss the move but on the flip side I was uneasy with price moving against my entry area too much.
...
time to re-read the MADA post... again, and again... and again.
 
Hello,

Just an example of my (typical) first trade.

Long at 9:45:39 at 1509.75

Reason to get in: point 3 up. (outside bar)

Got out the next bar at 1510.25

Reason to get out: bar 4 and bar 5 did not show increasing PRV. Increasing PRV is what we need after a point 3. The 9:50 bar could just as well have formed a point 3 down.

Just a note: I do realize YM was moving sideways from 9:46 - 9:54

The result: profit +.5 but missed a 6+ point move.

What mistake did I make?

regards,
Ivo
 

Attachments

Quote from ivob:

...What mistake did I make?
Not Holding.

Seriously, decreasing black volume in an up channel is what? A lateral. So we had lateral price movement to a NEW pt3 (bar 6) up of a STEEPER up channel.

Note for today: check out the first three bars again. Today is not 'typical'. What insight could this have given us to hold that first trade?

Here was my result:
<img src=http://elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=1708702>
 

Attachments

Hi,

Interesting to see we have the same entry.

First two bars: increasing red. The third bar is change and after that price was moving sideways indeed (could be seen well on YM) but I was already out.

But the outside bar broke the tape to the upside. 9:45 could just as well have formed a point 3 down. We did not get increasing PRV at the 9:45 bar or the 9:50 bar and it is not a bad idea to quickly get out then (it saved me in the past). Apart from this (my) str/sq did not give a signal. So how long should we wait for increasing PRV?

So my thinking was: bar 1 + 2 increasing red (so now we know the dominant is red). Then retracement (decr black) and point 3 down.

regards,
Ivo



Quote from Avi 8:

Not Holding.

Seriously, decreasing black volume in an up channel is what? A lateral. So we had lateral price movement to a NEW pt3 (bar 6) up of a STEEPER up channel.

Note for today: check out the first three bars again. Today is not 'typical'. What insight could this have given us to hold that first trade?

Here was my result:
<img src=http://elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=1708702>
 
Quote from ivob:

...But the outside bar broke the tape to the upside. 9:45 could just as well have formed a point 3 down....
So why didn't you go short? Did what must come after a pt 3 down, 'happen'?

Try looking at the exit as a point where one might short. If it isn't a good entry for a short, perhaps waiting is a good idea.
 
Quote from Avi 8:

So why didn't you go short? Did what must come after a pt 3 down, 'happen'?

Try looking at the exit as a point where one might short. If it isn't a good entry for a short, perhaps waiting is a good idea.

Hi,

Increasing red should have happened + the uptape broken. (in reversed order :-)

The tape up was broken to the downside but no increasing red.

However, it's the same story here. Price could have gone down until 1508 before we would even see or notice the increasing red... Should I have allowed price to go 2 points against my point of entry?

And even if it had gone back until 1508 it could have just as easily gone up until 1520 just as it did.

Anyway, I think it was a minor mistake to exit. The bigger mistake was not getting long again after my CO channel was broken on increasing volume / when the 9:50 bar was taken out. the 9:56 YM bar was very clear. I was still writing my log.

Another way to explain this is that price did try to make a point 3 down that failed on the 6th bar.

regards,
Ivo
 
Quote from Avi 8:
nice job mike, thanks for posting your trade.

Not Holding.

Seriously, decreasing black volume in an up channel is what? A lateral. So we had lateral price movement to a NEW pt3 (bar 6) up of a STEEPER up channel.

Note for today: check out the first three bars again. Today is not 'typical'. What insight could this have given us to hold that first trade?

Here was my result:
<img src=http://elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=1708702>
:cool: :cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top