You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Should I leave ET?
- Thread starter James Stock
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
Quote from spect8or:
Regardless of whether or not those that vote (c) "secretly want" Jimmy to leave, they believe that he should not be asked to leave; which is the same as saying he should stay.
Get it? Given that their principle is that no one should be asked to leave, they, by implication, believe that Jimmy should not be asked to leave.
And it's not "either way". They didn't vote "no one should be asked to leave or stay". Which is what would have been required for the argument you are making. They clearly expressed that no should be asked to leave. Whether they believe no should be asked to stay, to post or to say a Hail Mary is information that we are simply not privy to.
And Jimmy didn't say he would leave if "the majority ASK him to leave". He said if the poll received sufficient reponse he would "honor" it. But nice try.
your wrong.
yes, they "believe he should not be asked to leave" but this is NOT same thing as saying "STAY!" If they wanted to cast an affirmative vote for jimmie to STAY it is a simple as voting "STAY JIMMIE!" DUH! But they did not! They have, in effect, abstained from voting either way. Even if they want him to leave [or stay] they aren't going to ASK him for whatever their reasons [or they would have cast vote "a" or "b"]. Jimmie says he will go if the majority ASK ASK ASK him to leave. The majority has ASKED him to go. "c" did not ask him to leave nor did they ask him to stay either! Therefore, he should GO! GET IT!!?? Geeez .. :-/
Quote from Ring of Truth:
Your sinking deeper and deeper.
1) WHERE does it say "Jimmy says he will go if the majority ASK him to leave"? You say this was said, so show US where it was said.
2) Why do you never rebute statistical evidence that you voted 10 times late wednesday evening? The odds of this happening in a legit manner are over 1,000 to 1.
3) Why don't you understand that when someone asks "should I leave?" and the answer is "no one should be asked to leave", that these people are saying "NO!"
Longshit, you are proving no high school education and no statistics classes are a deadly mix in the intellect of life.
you are so stupid.
1) If this isn't what jimmie is saying then just what is he saying [iyo]??
2) your stats are almost as big a joke as your one-celled brain.
3) your reading tooooo much info from "c" . this is YOUR take but you are WRONG!!
:-/
Quote from waggie945:
There are 31 votes that have been cast to expel James Stock off of ET.
Jesus, how many more votes do you need to see that you are a TOTAL MORON!
:eek:
sorry, Charlie. A moderator, who asked to remain anonymous, has confirmed longshit voted 10 times late wednesday night. I already knew this, as its a statistical impossibility for those 10 votes to be legit.
The vote is now 21-16-15. That's 21 of 52 people who are saying "Yes, he should leave". A minority if there ever was one.
Quote from Ring of Truth:
sorry, Charlie. A moderator, who asked to remain anonymous, has confirmed longshit voted 10 times late wednesday night. I already knew this, as its a statistical impossibility for those 10 votes to be legit.
The vote is now 21-16-15. That's 21 of 52 people who are saying "Yes, he should leave". A minority if there ever was one.
Look who's making crap up now. HA! :-/
Quote from LongShot:
your wrong.
yes, they "believe he should not be asked to leave" but this is NOT same thing as saying "STAY!" If they wanted to cast an affirmative vote for jimmie to STAY it is a simple as voting "STAY JIMMIE!" DUH! But they did not! They have, in effect, abstained from voting either way. Even if they want him to leave [or stay] they aren't going to ASK him for whatever their reasons [or they would have cast vote "a" or "b"]. Jimmie says he will go if the majority ASK ASK ASK him to leave. The majority has ASKED him to go. "c" did not ask him to leave but they did NOT ask him to stay either! Therefore, he should GO! GET IT!!?? Geeez .. :-/
But they don't have the option of casting the vote "stay" because the poll doesn't offer it. According to you, they should have voted (b).
But why should we simply accept your take on it? Especially since it is highly illogical. As James said, in a poll that asks "should I leave, how in the world do you manage to interpret the response "no one should be asked to leave" as anything but a vote for Jimmy to stay?
Even if these (c) people do want Jimmy to leave, because they believe that no one should be asked to, they are, by default, agreeing he should stay. Why they don't want to ask him to is immaterial. They are not asking him to. If the question was "should I stay"? And they said "no one should be asked to leave", then there would indeed be difficulty in interpreting their response. As it is, there is none. It is quite clear.
And again, Jimmy does not say he will leave if the majority "ASK ASK ASK" him to. Longshot says that. Jimmy says he will honor the poll. Read his first post.
(c) did not 'abstain'. They voted. Abstaining means not voting. Quite elementary.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.