They are thinking as options (volatility) traders, and your strategy is a directional one. I prefer to do the opposite, sell calls at strikes where I would want to be short, but as I said the light isn’t worth the candle.
You are thinking at expiration.
By the time you get there, price whipsaw could come against you for more than the tiny credit you take.
Well I won't start to hedge at expiration, but any time before if the price gets sufficiently close to the strike. I want to avoid having to own the underlying since a dipping underling can outweigh the gain of the premium, but once the calls are ITM I definitely want them covered.
The point of this is to earn the premium, not trade volatility per se, although the moment of sale would happen at a time of unusually high IV and not some random moment in time. So the calls will be held until expiration.
You know what, I'm gonna backtest it with tick data and see if it's a viable strategy.
Do you plan on covering the calls 1:1? IOW, are you short 10 calls and buying 1000 shares if it nears the strike?
I know a guy who's worth >100MM and has traded vol for 20Y in bank stocks. He was on the underwriting side of the biz. He made 5 last year shorting vol on bank stocks. I asked him, "isn't the vol bottom decile?" and he answered that he has no idea where the vols are.
You gotta be in the market to make it!