POLL for traders who trade the Jack Hershey method(s) in real time with real money

[Cocaine]

Man, you are one whiny little bitch T28.

Quote from firestorm:

Oh you wont get that, Jack cant afford to be clear and concise, otherwise his method would be exposed as a simple little channel and volume system that nobody is making money from

4 years and not one of them has the balls to call live trades

 

[Cocaine]

Has it occurred to you that all you do is whine about Jack Hershey?

Quote from firestorm:


Has it occurred to you yet that all you do is whine about T28

 

[doli]

The Kool-Aid in Jonestown was "free," too.

 

[Trader666]

Here's a one page summary I put together that's mostly direct quotes from Jack and his "A Team," along with some editing by me:
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=1095707&highlight=nutshell#post1095707

Quote from doli:
What I am looking for is a clear explanation of the method.

 

[Cocaine]

Can dish it out but cant take it

Quote from firestorm:

Tissue?

 

[doli]

Quote from Trader666:

Here's a one page summary I put together that's mostly direct quotes from Jack and his "A Team," along with some editing by me:
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=1095707&highlight=nutshell#post1095707

Jack mentions "compare and contrast." Why doesn't he do that for Hershey Method vs. Channel Trading and Hershey Method vs. Trend Trading? As far as I can tell, Hershey Method is some complicated form of channel trading. Channel trading is well known, so why did Hershey think he needed to "add value" to it? Is he aware that he is trying to present a confused form of something that has already been done?
Is he deliberately confusing what has already been done?

 

[marketsurfer]

Quote from doli:

Jack mentions "compare and contrast." Why doesn't he do that for Hershey Method vs. Channel Trading and Hershey Method vs. Trend Trading? As far as I can tell, Hershey Method is some complicated form of channel trading. Channel trading is well known, so why did Hershey think he needed to "add value" to it? Is he aware that he is trying to present a confused form of something that has already been done?
Is he deliberately confusing what has already been done?

yes.


there is nothing new under the sun when it comes to TA.


complication is done for self aggrandizement or profit by selling the idea. nothing else makes sense.
surf

 

[Thunderdog]

Quote from marketsurfer:

...complication is done for self aggrandizement or profit by selling the idea. nothing else makes sense.
surf

I agree.

EDIT: Actually, there is an additional possibility. If you feel that people are getting dangerously close to exploiting an elegant, simple and useful idea, whatever it may be, you may then have to obfuscate and complicate in order to keep them running in circles and bumping into one another. Theoretically speaking, of course.

And then there are the pet owners who keep raising the treat ever so slightly just above Fido's reach. Why? Because they can. And that brings us back to self-aggrandizement.

 

[Cocaine]

No free lunch piker, do your own work

Quote from firestorm:

Whilst Jack and the kool aid gang refuse to offer any proof they must be regarded as frauds, liars and loons

Come on Jack ya yella belly bitch, call live trades, or get your cabana boy Spytrader to do it... one of you grow a set and ante up

 

[JimmyJam]

Quote from firestorm:

Whilst Jack and the kool aid gang refuse to offer any proof they must be regarded as frauds, liars and loons

Come on Jack ya yella belly bitch, call live trades, or get your cabana boy Spytrader to do it... one of you grow a set and ante up

LOL - the call live trades tirade.

I think see a short coming in the ES, c/o the Jack Hershey method.

S @ 1411.50, PS @ 1413.50

JJ