POLL for traders who trade the Jack Hershey method(s) in real time with real money

If you actually trade with real money using Jack's method in real time, please vote:

  • I have traded Jack's method(s) for over 6 months with real money in real time, and I [b]made[/b] mon

    Votes: 64 32.0%

  • I have traded Jack's method(s) for over 6 months with real money in real time, and I [b]lost[/b] mon

    Votes: 136 68.0%
  • Total voters
    200
Quote from Thunderdog:

That is comforting to know. It would have been quite an ordeal for you to have to drive for 3 hours all the way back to his place to ask him for his phone number or e-mail address. How unfortunate that neither of you thought to exchange any such contact information at all before you actually embarked on your 3-hour journey. I'm just glad it all worked out.
More...

Thunderdog. The new Tampa. :)
 
Quote from JimmyJam:

LOL - the call live trades tirade.

I think see a short coming in the ES, c/o the Jack Hershey method.

S @ 1411.50, PS @ 1413.50

JJ
More...

Trade stopped out @ -2pts. (anticipated)

Re-short @ 1414.00, PS @ 1416.00

FTT on 5 min time frame.
 

Attachments

We had previously communicated via PM here but once he turned it off, so went my communicaton stream with him :D.

He realized that and turned it back on again so that we could swap info. Im glad he did, didnt want to lose touch with him!

Thanks for the concerned post :)

Quote from Thunderdog:

That is comforting to know. It would have been quite an ordeal for you to have to drive for 3 hours all the way back to his place to ask him for his phone number or e-mail address. How unfortunate that neither of you thought to exchange any such contact information at all before you actually embarked on your 3-hour journey. I'm just glad it all worked out.
More...
 
OK, here's an equity curve after running this on 1000 stocks over a five year period, as opposed to overfitting like you did! :)
Quote from makosgu:
NOW, NOW (ie. pun intended, haha)! Tell the whole story T6.
More...
 

Attachments

Quote from Trader666:

OK, here's an equity curve after running this on 1000 stocks over a five year period, as opposed to overfitting like you did! :)
More...

Don't forget to point out that you used the wrong portfolio(s)... AHA
 
Quote from firestorm:

Whoa whoa JJ, that cant be Jack's method, he never has a single loss

and according to Harold it is impossible to trade this method and call live trades because it is so taxing

You guys all need to get your stories straight :D :D :D
More...

Different strokes for different folks m'man.

You see how people couldn't even figure out your sweet simple system.


JJ
 
Quote from Trader666:

OK, here's an equity curve after running this on 1000 stocks over a five year period, as opposed to overfitting like you did! :)
More...
the traditional way of backtest is to cover as large number of stocks as you can for a long period of time as long as you can get the data. I see you are doing that.
 
Quote from firestorm:

Does this method ever actually produce a winner?

strange for a 100% strike rate :p

Jesus I've had 3 winners in that time, don't tell me trading with only price and volume on a chart kicks the shit out of Mr Hershey's complicated channel system? surely not?

I guess thats the difference between a trader and an academic :p
More...

Odd, I didn't see your calls. :cool:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top