Quote from RichardRimes:
I give up...Safilo you obviously don't trade for a living.....I'm done wasting my time.
I did have one more contribution to the fly discussion however. I listen to Tom and Tony on tastytrade occasionally and in one of their market measures they have done some study on when the IV is above the 50% (of its average IV) doing what "they" call Big dog or Big Boy b-flys and closing them at 25% profit is like almost 100% winning strat. Most of the time its earnings plays. They think they have found the "holy grail"...I kinda lol'd a bit because that is exactly what Riskattypru has been doing for years with pretty good success. Yes they lost big on GOOG as did many others but over all success rate has been pretty dam good.

Quote from Safilo:
Sorry, but no. A butterfly is never "directional" because it narrowly defined profit range. Placing it OTM doesn't make it a directional position - it's still a neutral position because it will not gain or lose with the market. It has a fixed max profit and loss.
Quote from RichardRimes:
thats the "edge" of the bottom feeder retail trader...our size is so small nobody notices
your right the commissions are the big downside...it definitely has to weigh in the total calculation of p/l