I have found that the majority of those who want a mentor are really seeking the Holy Grail. It might be there but I haven't found it. The closest thing I have found is having a well thought out plan and having the discipline to follow it.
I’m not sure it has to have an edge over everyone else but it has to have a statistically proven probability of making money in the long run.
My strategy is a simple reversal strategy that only has a few criteria. It has a win rate of 40% but the wins are larger than the losses. Year after year it makes a profit. I consider part of my edge as having the discipline to take the next trade after having a series of losses. You know following my plan.
I’d hazard a guess that more traders fail from lack of discipline than from not having a defined edge.
Once in a while someone who so obviously gets it raises his hand. Once in a very great while.