Quote from JimmyJam:
The market opened at your Value Point, meandered for an hour, and then blew off for the days high of probably 1312 or so.
The market never traded below the 40 SMA, so a Sell Signal was never triggered.
As it is currently constituted, your trading methodology continues to ignore the dominant trend of the market, thus while your value areas are significant for what they represent (the point at which the highest number of contracts traded in the previous trading session), you are not trading them correctly and probably have a win rate of something around 50/50 (wins/losses).
With a 4 pt stop and a 4 pt target that gives you a negative expectation after commissions.
I'd examine the method a little closer and attempt to get it at least in the 55/45 (or higher) range before committing any real capital to it.
Best Regards,
Jimmy