SimpleMeLike,
Agree with you 100% on there being no right or wrong style of trading, Trend or RTM. Ultimately the only thing that matters is P&L.
But there is a big difference in being a Vendor of hopes and dreams trading 1 minute breakouts and trying to entertain the members and a humble trader. I think your ability to learn from a losing trade is infinitely greater than Andrews who has tens of thousands of dollars flowing in each month to gamble with.
Come on, a 1 minute ORB (Opening Range Breakout) where $38K was gambled and lost because of a feeling? Why? That shit can be tested with numerous target and stop combinations to see if there is a positive expectancy - edge.
Here is my "feeling", I'd believe you a thousand times over the confession of a vendor gambling monthly member's funny money. Gambling membership money in a bull market is not an edge. Confessions of such a vendor is just marketing damage control.
Godspeed to your profits
View attachment 241490
LMAO hahah I agree They.
Here is a true story.
They, you and I already know whats going with this story here. I use to be in a similar paid chat room when I first start trading. Man, that teacher in that chat room, had me sooooo messed up, I was scared to take short trades for about 6 months trading the ES. Trying to catch the falling knife, to get the big RR, and then brag about the big big winner. One day, a FOMC day, I tried to follow him catching the strong bear move down. That ES kept on going down and we kept on trying to buy. I think I lost about $2000 that day. The guy was saying the same thing this teacher is saying about the worst day ever. The really really
sad part, was on that day I had a college buddy join the room too who was new to trading. He never traded before, maybe a few times. He took those trades too, and he lost about $6000 because he refuse to sell and held the trade for about 2 days.
I thought about that $2000 lost all weekend. I came to conclusion, there is noway this trading where I sit around waiting for price to fall all week, and then just buy, lose, buy again, lose, buy again, lose buy again......and hope I get a big 20 point gain and then feel happy. Logic prevailed. I started asking, why this person no short while the price is falling. I asked why, and the response was "Dummy money, sell when the price is already falling".
That room pushed my trading back by about 1-2 years cause all I knew was "ok catch the ES when its alllll the way down, and buy and hold for the big money"
After joining ET and talk to a few experienced traders, I left that room.
The point I am saying is, people have to be careful who they are paying money to to teach them, cause that learning can push your trading skills back far and cause other damage.