Quote from Ghost of Cutten:
How about some discussion of valuations and expected long-run returns, rather than just short-term macro themes. With high quality, low-debt, blue chip multinational franchise stocks selling at 8-10% earnings yields, compared to 2.8% on US Treasuries, one has to ask how important some temporary macro headwinds are going to be.
Feel free to get the ball rolling, as you clearly have an opinion here...
The first devil's advocate question I would ask is, which blue chip franchises do you see at an 8-10% yield, and if the case for value there is as compelling as you suggest, why are investors falling all over themselves to lend to IBM at 1% and McDonald's at 3.5%.
Also, how about Hussman's take on
misvaluation via questionable forward operating earnings estimates, coupled with his assertion that, by more reliable historical measures, stocks are ~ 40% overvalued.
Re, expected long run returns, I would have to ask, expected returns for whom and regarding what strategy? The viewpoint of a swing trader, for example, will be very different than that of a long-term investor... as will the viewpoint of someone with a "fully invested" mandate versus another who is comfortable using rapidly-deployed leverage and switching in and out of cash...
Also, whether the macro headwinds are "temporary" or severe and lasting seems a major debate of the day, and not something trivial in the least... if China turns out to be a potemkin village, for example -- or at least a grossly overhyped / overinflated one -- then it could be a very rough couple years ahead for the global economy.