Is scalping still profitable?

I've been learning to scalp since early November. Yes, I'm very very new at this.
...
Keeping it simple has worked for me. I trade emini S&P 500 on a 2000 tick chart, a 21 bar EMA, and a ATM strategy with a profit target and stop loss. I read the price action, that's it.
...
Whoever says day trading is easy is full of it. It's a lot of hard work and commitment.

Is scalp trading profitable? I would have to say it is.

However long you've been trading via a certain set of rules/procedures/protocols, count on those working only maybe for another quarter. Have other irons in the fire, and compare performance monthly if not weekly. The markets lending you good performance right now WILL change, and will go away. And if you're only set to hunt rabbits, but the woods and by-ways are only offering ducks, you're going to go hungry. Being an opportunist means not only seeking opportunities in areas you've targeted, but seeking new targets, as well. Have a plan, *trade* that plan, and when you don't see the trades, DON'T trade.
 
You let an NQ trade go 950 points against you and you are talking to me about magical mystical numbers ? Anybody see the irony in this ?

Hey, that's the nature of true swing trading the NQ, although its a bit more heady than usual as of late.
 
You let an NQ trade go 950 points against you and you are talking to me about magical mystical numbers ? Anybody see the irony in this ?

Today is another great example of the nature of swing these days...

Look at these pics, and look at the hi-lo ranges, and the movement. This is why my swing trading is on pause. Yeah, I let a NQ position go against me 950 points over the course of a month, and got out with a 550 point loss. Before that, it would have would have taken months for that to bear itself out. But at the time of my real trade, it took the course of 5-6 weeks.

Now it is down to a day for that scenario to play out.

So ESkiller, don't you snap at my ass. We're in a whole other world of trading now, on the swing side. I'm now needling down on scalping the day for 30-40 points on a contract, instead of 3-4 ticks on 100 contracts. I do not wonder how your tenant is doing now, I am sure he/she is in an E-Trade commercial by now. I wish I was your tenant, I am jealous. ESKiller. I hope you killed it today.

insane manalyzer1218a.jpg
 
Today is another great example of the nature of swing these days...

Look at these pics, and look at the hi-lo ranges, and the movement. This is why my swing trading is on pause. Yeah, I let a NQ position go against me 950 points over the course of a month, and got out with a 550 point loss. Before that, it would have would have taken months for that to bear itself out. But at the time of my real trade, it took the course of 5-6 weeks.

Now it is down to a day for that scenario to play out.

So ESkiller, don't you snap at my ass. We're in a whole other world of trading now, on the swing side. I'm now needling down on scalping the day for 30-40 points on a contract, instead of 3-4 ticks on 100 contracts. I do not wonder how your tenant is doing now, I am sure he/she is in an E-Trade commercial by now. I wish I was your tenant, I am jealous. ESKiller. I hope you killed it today.

View attachment 196207

I have no interest in arguing. Just related a story of someone that got me into trading and u act as if i'm telling lies. We are no longer in touch as we had a falling out years ago but I doubt he's still trading much these days. He wasn't a perfect trader but he made $ and always traded big. As to my own trading, I did well today. Hope you did too
 
I have no interest in arguing. Just related a story of someone that got me into trading and u act as if i'm telling lies. ...

Indeed, I will also let this intra-thread convo die. Will not lead to good outcome in this section.
 
Here's a chart I just marked up for anyone looking for some scalping help. Granted its after the fact, there's some good principles in here if u an understand my wording. THis is 1 minute NQ
 

Attachments

  • dec 26 ANALYSIS.jpg
    dec 26 ANALYSIS.jpg
    582.9 KB · Views: 132
Today is another great example of the nature of swing these days...

Look at these pics, and look at the hi-lo ranges, and the movement. This is why my swing trading is on pause. Yeah, I let a NQ position go against me 950 points over the course of a month, and got out with a 550 point loss. Before that, it would have would have taken months for that to bear itself out. But at the time of my real trade, it took the course of 5-6 weeks.

Now it is down to a day for that scenario to play out.

So ESkiller, don't you snap at my ass. We're in a whole other world of trading now, on the swing side. I'm now needling down on scalping the day for 30-40 points on a contract, instead of 3-4 ticks on 100 contracts. I do not wonder how your tenant is doing now, I am sure he/she is in an E-Trade commercial by now. I wish I was your tenant, I am jealous. ESKiller. I hope you killed it today.

View attachment 196207
seems optimistic
 
You know something; accepting the fact that things could go wrong is one of the major problems we have in the market. And since we don't have this reality in mind we just get really upset when things do go wrong and make more poor decisions out of haste.
 
Scalping is profitable and will always be. The only problem is that, not all brokers allow that type of trading. A few of them do allow it. I trade on the Forexchief mt4 platform and they don't have any rules against scalping.
 
Back
Top