So if all humans vanished, there would be no ideas remaining?
And if all radios vanished, there would be no radio waves traveling in space?
Quite funny.
"Thus, in the absence of the human species, there are no ideas at all at least no human ideas"
That would mean the theory of evolution would not be true in an independent manner at all, the concept of random chance would not exist without a human being having "thunk it" which means that all this evolutionary babble is nothing but a product of the human mind, not a natural process that existed, or exists independent of the human mind's sustaining an idea of it.
Mathematical truths would cease to exist as ideas because no one could think them?
Again, too funny.
All scientific theory (just a bunch of ideas) are not actual discoveries of that which exists independent of human thought are just products of human mind, not a true condition that preceded human mind's thought process. Those who promote theories are not actually examining fact of nature independent of human mind, they are just advancing a byproduct of some electrical impulses.
Yall are pee in your pants funny.
In this physical universe, is there anything that can come into being without the potential to come into being first preceding it?
Show how actuality comes to be without the potential to come to be first.
The Universe came into being from no potential (i.e. the math) for a Universe?
You really do believe in magic...or the cart before the horse.
Quote from kjkent1:
Asked and answered.
As for your statement that symbolism is non-physical. Well, thanks for your opinion, but I don't agree. In my opinion, there is no idea without the electrochemical actions of a human brain to thunk it.
Thus, in the absence of the human species, there are no ideas at all (at least no human ideas -- there may be dolphin ideas -- which could even be thunk on porpoise).:eek: