Yeah, I hear what you are saying. I've been experimenting with scalping. My win rate(which is always deceptive) is almost 100%(at least high 90s). If buy then offer out a few seconds later I always win. I find it exhausting to trade like that. Maybe I just need to train myself. Just experimenting with this style vs the pure chart analysis that holds for 10-30mins to an hour.
I feel like 2 ES Points or the equivalent in YM/NQ points isn't that hard. But you have to account for losses. All is great when you are doing fine. But losses is where they get ya...
Let's see how this experiment goes...
If your scalping is really that profitable, you should program a auto-trading system to trade it instead of manually trading it. I agree manual scalping is a killer.