You lost me at "BS is good because I can use it in business and make money, then I'm not even trying to touch that argument because that's not what I'm talking about"..
In the real world,Trading,not academia,that is all that matters.
Its similar to saying BJJ is flawed as its not terribly effective in standup,but the BJJ practitioner mauls every "decent" stand up striker out there...
Simply put,it appears to be very effective,however flawed.
Now you could make the argument that pure BJJ practitioners have met their match in MMA with guys cross training in Boxing,Muay Thai,Judo,Wrestling. Agreed...
But until you demonstrate that you have come up with a far superior model which takes advantage of BS flaws and "mispricing", BS is as good as it gets...
If you want to be the best,you have to beat the champ