Quote from Unquestionably:
Excuse all the negativity below, but I simple feel the need to vent:
Ten Reasons Why Trading Sucks, and Why You Should Go Into Business Instead
1. In business, you can turn $5k into $100k's. In trading, you need at least $100k.
***Wow, let me know which one this is, I got 5G's for ya.
2. In business, you can be making millions after five years. In trading, you need at least 5 years of learning to average $20k/year, only then do you get to see low-mid 6 figures a year.
*** See above reply.
3. In business, you can set aside as much capital as you need to expand. In stock trading, you are limited to $50k / swing trade. Put anymore capital in and the manipulator will freak out and back out from their original plan, leaving you with a failed pattern.
***What????? I don't get it
4. In business, you soon have cash flow. In trading, your cash flow sucks or is non-existant until after the 5th year.
***Uh, sorry to tell you this, MOST businesses fail within the first 5 years.
5. In business, you don't feel like committing suicide if it fails. You simple start another venture. In trading, you don't like how you feel after a significant draw down.
****Really? Have you ever owned a business, I disagree here, more than once, a client stiffed me for more than $25k, Lien's? yeah right, only if they sell the property, then you have to continue the "perfection" of the lien, or lose your lien rights,......next.
6. In business, you exploit other ppl's weaknesses. In stock trading, you wait behind the bush to ambush the innocent.
***I disagree here too, you CAN offer a very desirable service, we did a lot of hospital work, built some MRI and Oncology suites in the pediatric wings,.....I liked doing that for the kids. And I was paid for it.
7. In business, at least ppl get something in return for giving you their money. In trading, ppl are left with nothing after giving you their money (coveting other ppl's properties).
***The market is an auction, plain and simple,...manipulated? You bet.
Ambushing people? That's a bit harsh, right? If you and I differ on the direction of something, and I am wrong,....you win,.....period.
8. Most great stock traders committed suicide after they lost everything (Jesse Livermore, Nicolas Darvas). Most great business men lived on after they've lost their fortune (William Durant).
***Here's one that'll kill you,.....Have you done any research on the people that lived and invested in tech companies in the Silicon Valley area, AFTER the tech bubble burst.
9. In business, you can go on vacation. In stock trading, you must be present online every single trading day (or check on the behavior of your 'system').
***Wrong on both accounts. It takes more work to go on vacation when you "own" a business, than to close your positions, and leave. Can you say, "GTC" order?
10. In business, you face competition and your income dwindles slowly, giving you time to react. In trading, your 'system' stops working suddenly.
I replied next to each of your ideas,......with 3 ***'s
***You have control over your "system", you do NOT have control over local and global economic factors that do have a direct impact on your business.
Sorry, just had to chime in here:
My experience, (business), owner operator medium size contracting firm, 15 employees, sold business June 2010 after 20 years in business, 30 years in the trade.
Clients included, Coca-Cola, Neutrogena, Jack in the box, and quite a few other high profile names.
Doubters, email me, I'l direct you to website for further scrutiny.
What I wanted to say, was Trading IS a business, just like any other. No different. Everyone has a different emotional temperment for any type of business.
Not everyone is cut out to do construction for as long as I did.
I was not cut out to sit in an office environment.
Some people do not have the patience that is REQUIRED to venture into ANY profession.
We all need to find our "groove" and passion.
Unless you have sufficient start up capital, or take a loan, you are pissing up a wet rope.
It took me 10 years to build a client base that could carry my operating expenses to a point that it could pay me 6 figures a year.
ANY business will suffer set backs, mine went through 3 recession cycles over the years, and the last one diminished my annual volume by 70%.
Luckily, I was at the end of my career, and sold the business to the top guys in the firm for an amount that pays me a small salary each month.
I have spent the last 3 years learning the "electronic" side of trading, as I was a series 7 broker in my early 20's, (salesman), but that is where I found, and maintained a passion for the markets for over 20 years.
I have only been trading for real for 1 year, learning the last 3 and I am NOT profitable yet, nor do I make any bones about it.
I have an exit plan for the business, (maximum time and drawdown)
Do NOT be lured by the sway of the perception of easy money in ANY business venture.
My experience has taught me that, to work for myself, means I have to work 3 times harder than for anyone else.
it's NOT what we do 9-5 that gets us ahead, it's AFTER that, that will make the difference.
Sorry for the rant, but I would suggest looking to the more experienced traders here for help,......I'm not one of them.
I am still learning everyday.
One has to re-evaluate their business model all the time, whatever business you are in.
I am finally at the place where I know a little bit more than I did yesterday,.....which is to say, "never stop learning".
Find your passion, and stay with it,........money is secondary, fulfillment is everything.
My .02