Quote from Brass:
You missed the point, as usual. One would think that a supreme being would communicate in no uncertain terms, especially to us lower-order creatures, in order to make himself plain. Apparently not.
Schooling is an affair of state. Come on Mnpharts.Quote from Mnphats:
The captive audience was Catholic. Then the idiotic mumbling of separation of church from state in a Catholic school? Come on Stupid.
Quote from stu:
Schooling is an affair of state. Come on Mnpharts.
Kids have to go to school. Private or public schools cannot do whatever the hell they want. The key word is school, not religious indoctrination camp.
Quote from stu:
You're right, it wasn't a good analogy.
A mandatory assembly is not a meeting where people are taking part of their own free will. If the catholic church can do that, then so should PETA and the KKK, when they too can be resisted by school children obliged to attend.
Then you or someone else can make that asinine remark again, that it's merely fashionable to attack the preaching of bigoted attitudes that belong in the dark ages.
Bullshit on your one too. Simplistic sweeping statements like that don't score. A private school cannot legally teach whatever they want. To use an extreme, are you trying to suggest a catholic school would be legally free to preach incitement to commit murder? Of course not. Free to preach and teach intolerance and hatred of fellow pupils by their race religion or whether they were adopted is what parents role into a school for? Are you serious? Next you'll be telling me the government, in the form of law, should be kept out of catholic child rape, because the state cannot mandate that kind of 'curriculum' which they were running worldwide.Quote from Wallet:
Bullshit on this one, a private school can teach whatever they want, and a public school can't stop a child from professing they faith.
Christian, Catholic what ever schools are there because Parents enroll their children in them wanting their children to be taught both religion and academics.
Separation of Church and State was instituted for this very reason, not to keep Religion out of Government but to keep Government out of Religion.... The state can't mandate a private/religious schools curriculum, unless they want to try and blackmail them.
The Catholic spokesperson in this instance choose their words very unwisely, however it doesn't negate the fact that children from broken ,single-parent households are at a disadvantage......not even going to touch non traditional same sex partnered families if you want to stretch the definition.
The analogy was comparing meetings to captive audiences - and hateful preaching by catholics against the sexual orientation and antecedence of other children , some of whose adopted parents had decided for them they were catholic - being disrupted by more catholics, presumably by parents who decided for them that they were catholic too .Quote from PiggyBank:
Actually his analogy was fine. The school is most likely a private, catholic school, students who can't attend mandatory meetings because they don't believe what the church is selling - should attend another school. the church is what it is and has been that way for centuries, they and their families know what they are getting into when they enroll there.
If it is in fact a public school then there shouldn't be any mandatory religious meetings.