How do u know u have made it in daytrading?

Thanks... something I'm earnestly trying to master is filtering the breakout setups with volume and velocity. However, it's still a work in progress...

Quote from NoDoji:

I didn't mean "the 4", rather "any 4" price action setups:

Price finds support at a higher low, go long.

Price found support at a higher low and is about to test the previous high, buy the new high.

Price finds resistance at a lower high, sell short.

Price found resistance at a lower high and is about to test the previous low, sell the new low.

Price is making higher lows and higher highs in a channel, buy at the bottom of the channel.

Price is making lower highs and lower lows in a channel, sell at the top of the channel.

Price made a strong run up and consolidates in a narrow range, buy a break through the high of the range.

Price made a strong move down and consolidates in a narrow range, buy a break through the low of the range.

I've never seen a 5-min intraday chart where these kinds of setups fail to occur and have expected follow through at least enough times in a given day to end up mildly profitable if you trade them.
 
Quote from HowardCohodas:

jack hershey,

You seemed to have hijacked my response to a paragraph from an earlier post to an end that I cannot fathom. I can't figure out what point you are trying to make or how it relates to the original paragraph.

__________________
Author - "These Seven Trading (Investing) Secrets Will Explode Your Account: All I Know About Trading (Investing) I Learned in Flight School"

You arent the first and certainly not the last-JH exists just like the exhaust from the CLS550 sport, just like poop after a nice dinner, just like a hangover after a good night out with friends etc etc etc I could make it a one page post but u get the drift....
 
Quote from NoDoji:

This is how easy it is for an average retail day trader to blow up while trading according to solid rules. You go long a $20 stock in an established uptrend with 2x leverage out of the 4x leverage you have available on your $50K trading account. Never risking more than 2% of your account on a trade, you place a .20 stop loss to protect your capital and are looking to capture a .40 profit as soon price makes an expected new high.

Suddenly trading is halted and very bad news is released. When trading resumes the best bid is $5.00, your stop loss triggers as a market order and you immediately lose $75K.

Good example - after watching the market like a hawk for over 5 years now only moves I have seen have been in direction of the setup-news followed the set up. Not saying it cant happen but imagine the opposite too making 75k in a day on a 50k account. Few years back i was short on a setup in AKAM and it was just a day trade that was in the money by about $1 and it dropped almost $5 in a heartbeat after they came out with earnings right in middle of the day-one happy camper -still remember it witha bright glow :) Too bad its only happened once while in the trade.
 
The simple answer.....you don't and you don't have to think about it...


Treat each trading day as the ONLY day......be grateful at the end of the day that you can do the same thing the next day....


And may the forces be with you...


NiN


P.S....I had a beautiful trade today.....then had my arse delivered to me ....and I did everything I was supposed to do...AAHHH!!!!

Tomorrow is another day....
 
Quote from jack hershey:
Here in ET when I hijack a thread I literally take it over and control all the thoughts of interest in that thread.
Interesting...
 
Quote from NoDoji:

This belief about having to adapt to changing markets over time as a day trader just makes no sense to me.

Quote from Redneck:

By the very nature of the way you trade - now

You are continually adapting – and with out consciously thinking about it... :)

Exactly my thought. Good trading all.
 
Quote from GG1972:

Good example - after watching the market like a hawk for over 5 years now only moves I have seen have been in direction of the setup-news followed the set up. Not saying it cant happen but imagine the opposite too making 75k in a day on a 50k account. Few years back i was short on a setup in AKAM and it was just a day trade that was in the money by about $1 and it dropped almost $5 in a heartbeat after they came out with earnings right in middle of the day-one happy camper -still remember it witha bright glow :) Too bad its only happened once while in the trade.

Once in a while it happens. I often somewhat hedge some of my option plays and have often missed out on big moves like a $50 pop in GOOG. However last week, I took a 20k loss to get rid of option I had on AAPL and got out just in time for a 60K gain. I ended up with a 45K plus day. Certainly not my normal trading day, but it nice to once in a while not just "wish I had that stock" when a big move happens. :)
 
Quote from NoDoji:

This is how easy it is for an average retail day trader to blow up while trading according to solid rules. You go long a $20 stock in an established uptrend with 2x leverage out of the 4x leverage you have available on your $50K trading account. Never risking more than 2% of your account on a trade, you place a .20 stop loss to protect your capital and are looking to capture a .40 profit as soon price makes an expected new high.

Suddenly trading is halted and very bad news is released. When trading resumes the best bid is $5.00, your stop loss triggers as a market order and you immediately lose $75K.

This is why traders should restrict themselves to very liquid markets. Futures are ideal. Of course, you can still get caught in nasty moves, especially in the ags. A newbie with a 50k trading account could trade 2 ES in relative safety.

If folk insist on trading stocks when they are learning, at the very least they should avoid leverage. Don't get me started on people who gamble buying cheap call options close to expiry and then get a reg T call when they are assigned. That is another foolproof way to blow up. (and of course they then start to carp about how they thought options were "limited risk". Not funny.)
 
Quote from NoDoji:

This belief about having to adapt to changing markets over time as a day trader just makes no sense to me. I agree that you may need to switch gears from trading a strong intraday trend to trading a range or trending channel, but whether the market as a whole is in a strong bull, a strong bear or a consolidation range, the intraday moves on popular futures contracts and high volume stocks will always offer a few trades every day that produce basic price action follow through IMHO.

The adaptation is necessary if you wish to move trading beyond pattern recognition. Any instrument will behave in a distinct manner depending on what location it is in in the overall trend. I would suggest that one needs to spend at least 5 years with one of the futures contracts you mention to see most of the conditions. All of this filters down into intraday trading.

Anyone who just looks for patterns will have very mixed results. Double tops for example. People who base their trading around double tops will have had a very hard time in the recent conditions, and without understanding why. Equally those who play breakouts will be getting hurt if they are shorting. Similarly those who use oscillators.

In 2003/4 and 2008 again adaptations needed to be made due to volatility and range. The trading plan needs to incorporate how to deal with the special issues which those markets presented. First, risk management must be taken care of. This will necessitate a reduction in position size due to liquidity issues and ranges. Next, a plan must be laid for dealing with the reduced reaction times. Finally, the trader must understand when not to be frightened by the speed of movement. There were some vicious shake outs which could scare improperly developed traders.

The condition in April this year was very similar to summer of 2007, and unless a trader had been through the former they would be unlikely to spot the imminent collapse, given that most traders were getting used to the new bull market.

The education process takes decades, however I'd postulate that five years is enough to see the majority of what is required, and understand the locations in the largest timeframes. Five years is also enough to flush out chronic bulls, chronic bears, stubborn traders, and those who cannot handle fast markets (or very quiet markets, see overtrading).
 
Back
Top