hmm.no edges in the markets
- Thread starter chimera
- Start date
Quote from cornix:
Haha... some of them even participated in this thread.
If they like, please share personal contact information I have a few questions to run by them. I don't place much faith in aliases.
surf
Quote from wrbtrader:
Timothy Sykes has and that girl has although I'm don't know the name of the girl. What's her name ?
Note: Timothy Sykes was once a member of ET and you did not attack him about his use of TA when he was here saying how successful of a trader he was and when he was "defending" his trade approach in penny stocks. Therefore, why didn't you call out your good friend Timothy Sykes
Can't you see that you have no integrity here at ET anymore after the price drivers fiasco along with you continuing to talk about how impressive someone is in their trading while minimizing their use of TA as if they are some sort'uv "exception" to our TA debate because you personally know them. You're only left with trolling from thread to thread to start TA arguments. It's getting pathetic don't you think.
Tim approaches TA as a part of an overall plan that includes information about a company-- this is completely different than starring at a commodity chart, with ZERO other information, and claiming to make consistent daily profits. I agree that as part of a complete trading plan, TA may have some merit-- however, as a stand alone, and I am including money management as part of the stand alone TA useage-- TA provides zero edge. I think you agree with me. surf
That's all you needed to say.
Therefore, stop debating with me about TA, stop asking for proof, stop the "dick measurement" competitions...aim your commentary to those that believe TA all by itself will work. You get no sympathy from me when you aim your TA debates towards me.
End of Story.
I'm sure they do, especially after the report
I never argued with you, WRB. My argument and challenges go to those who make claims and claim they earn consistent daily profits by price action alone ( with money management) in the commodity markets. If they do, its despite of TA, not because of it.
If you don't make claims or state price action alone with mm is all one needs for success, no argument from me--- I agree with you,
surf
Ok, my apologies. I misunderstood the following statement by you considering you and I have agreed many other occasions in the recent past about how profitable traders that are using TA...using such within a complete trading plan.
You have also participated in past discussions with cornix...someone that has specifically stated in his broker statement thread called "Cornix TA Performance" that he uses TA with other tools such as microscopic fundamental component. Yet, knowing that, you still bark at him often whenever he talks about TA.
The only reason why I mention cornix is because that's a frequent name you continue mentioning in your debates about TA.
Quote from cornix:
Speaking of edges in context of NoD's claims of what's possible at least in theory... while NQ as dull and not giving me trades I practice some simulated CL trading this week... just a couple hours a day as usual, cause now it's time for milk with some cake and sweet sleep.
for this thread, this is cherry-picking trades to make your point.