History and Movies

The Tuskegee Airmen are some of the greatest fighter pilots in aviation history.Its clear some people have a problem with that because they were black

No, what is clear is that you don't give a damn about the facts.
 
And, I'm not playing 'race card' or anything of the like. Just curious as to your point here. Other than that, it seems like a lot of hypebole over a movie.

Yes you are. Hyperbole? Obama ordered an Air Force One flight over New York for this thing and you say I am going over the top?

Blacks and liberals are obsessed with symbolism, that's my point.
 
IF I'm not mistaken they did have one ace. (I saw him interviewed once I think)

Given the large numbers of accidents in that era their kill ratio may actually have been even less than 2:1. Which is not very good for the time. Although I don't like making conjectures like that

No aces. Late 1944 to May 1945 was mop up time as far as the Luftwaffe was concerned. Even at 2:1 their record is not so great that you can say they were elite. The bomber crews did like them as they stuck to their mission.

99th Ftr Sqn
Edward L. Toppins, 4
Charles B. Hall, 3
Leonard M. Jackson, 3
Clarence W. Allen, 0.5
Willie Ashley, Jr., 1
Charles P. Bailey, 1
Howard L. Baugh, 1
Thomas P. Braswell, 1
Wm. A. Campbell, 1
John W. Davis, 1
Lemuel L. Curtis, 1
Robert W. Dier, 2
Elwood T. Driver, 1
Wilson V. Eagleson, 2
James L. Hall, 1
Clinton B. Mills, 1
Daniel L. Rich, 1
Leon C. Roberts, 1
Lewis C. Smith, 1
Hugh J. White, 1
100th Ftr Sqn
Raul W. Bell, 1
Charles V. Brantley, 1
John F. Briggs, 1
Roscoe C. Browne, 2
Richard W. Hall, 1
Jack D. Hosclaw, 2
Carl E. Johnson, 1
Langdon E. Johnson, 1
Earl R. Lane, 2
Clarence D. Lester, 2
John H. Lyle, 1
Walter J.A. Palmer, 1
Geo. M. Rhodes, Jr., 1
Robert W. Williams, 2
Bertram W. Wilson, Jr. 1
301st Ftr Sqn
Joseph D. Elsberry, 4
Carl E. Corey, 2
John E. Edwards, 2
James H. Fischer, 1
Fred. D. Funderburg, 2
Alfred M. Gorham, 2
Claude Govan, 1
Thomas W. Jefferson, 2
Jimmy Lanham, 2
Armour G. McDaniel, 1
Walter P. Manning, 1
Harold M. Morris, 1
William S. Price, III, 1
Harold E. Sawyer, 1
Harry T. Stewart, 2
Charles L. White, 2
302nd Ftr Sqn
Lee A. Archer, 4
Wendell O. Pruitt, 3
Roger Romaine, 3
Milton P. Brooks, 1
Charles W. Bussey, 1
Edward C. Gleed, 2
Wm. W. Green, Jr., 2
Weldon K. Groves, 1
William L. Hill, 1
Freddie F. Hutchins, 1
Melvin T. Jackson, 1
Felix J. Kirkpatrick, 1
Charles E. McGee, 1
Luther H. Smith, Jr., 2
Robert H. Smith, 2
William H. Thomas, 1
Hugh S. Warner, 1
Luke J. Weather, Jr., 2
L. D. Wilkins, 1
 
Quote from Mav88:

No aces....
I stand erected.

Apparently "some sources" gave Lee Archer credit for 4.5 or 5 kills which seems to be the source of the disparity.
 
http://articles.nydailynews.com/201..._1_tuskegee-airman-ace-pilot-air-force-pilots

Retired Air Force Lt. Colonel Lee A. Archer, lone ace Tuskegee Airman, dies at 90


THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER
Friday, January 29, 2010

NEW YORK- Retired Air Force Lt. Colonel Lee A. Archer, a Tuskegee Airman considered to be the only black ace pilot who also broke racial barriers as an executive at a major U.S. company and founder of a venture capital firm, died Wednesday in New York City. He was 90.

His son, Roy Archer, said his father died at Cornell University Medical Center in Manhattan. A cause of death was not immediately determined.

The Tuskegee Airmen were America's first black fighter pilot group in World War II.

"It is generally conceded that Lee Archer was the first and only black ace pilot," credited with shooting down five enemy planes, Dr. Roscoe Brown Jr., a fellow Tuskegee Airman and friend, said in a telephone interview Thursday.

Archer was acknowledged to have shot down four planes and he and another pilot both claimed victory for shooting down a fifth plane. An investigation revealed Archer had inflicted the damage that destroyed the plane, said Brown and the Air Force eventually proclaimed him an ace pilot.
 
Normally Archer would get 4.5 kills at most, it appears that someone tought there needed to be a black ace in 2010. In this age not surprising. I was going by the Air Force Historian's report in 2008.

So one after the fact ace, ok, does not affect the discussion much. Certainly does not make him one of the greatest of all time.
 
Quote from Mav88:

Yes you are. Hyperbole? Obama ordered an Air Force One flight over New York for this thing and you say I am going over the top?

Blacks and liberals are obsessed with symbolism, that's my point.

This from the team of W with his 'Mission Accomplished" banner and a flight suit. Come on.



c
 
Not to change the subject but is there some part of her assessment which is flawed? Forget bleeding heart political correctness for the moment.
It's a fact of life that sometimes the truth hurts. Personally I think our society is far more thin skinned to painful truths than we were even just a couple of generations ago. But I digress.

Just for the sake of argument, even if a particular group of people are inferior on average in one particular area. It doesn't necessarily mean they are inferior overall.

I'm old school constitution, we are equal in the eyes of the law. The beauty of liberty is it doesn't matter if one group is dumber or not because we all get equal rights. Enter liberalism and modern black racism, now equal opportunity isn't enough, now they insist on equal outcomes. However there is a big problem- blacks will not or cannot perform intellectually with whites or asians yet they want equal outcomes and keep banging the table with the permanent excuse as to why the white man has to keep paying.

In that context symbolism becomes a replacement for real achievement, and we get a president who believes in symbolism so strongly he would order that dumb NYC flyover and then lie about it.
 
This from the team of W with his 'Mission Accomplished" banner and a flight suit. Come on.

I didn't condone that, but at least it was an honest mistake.
 
Quote from Mav88:

I didn't condone that, but at least it was an honest mistake.

Not sure about 'honest mistake' - but much more to be concerned about, with much more at stake, than some movie 'based' on actual events, as posted earlier.

Look, I actually thought it was great that President Bush flew in with that accomplishment. Until, of course, we found out it was all bogus. I still respect the Office, even when it's so hard to deal with, especially their cronies. Hubris and all that. But still respect the President, Mr. Bush.


c
 
Back
Top