Quote from Martinghoul:
Most of the stuff that has been bought by the German/French banks in the roaring noughties was bought at par, trust me... I was there and traded some.
Moreover, we know that everything that's in the "accrual", "hold-to-maturity" books (and that's where the majority of the paper sits, according to balance sheet statements and stress test disclosures) is marked at par.
Therefore, no matter how you slice it, the French plan is punitive for the banks (my estimate is that it's equivalent to about a 20% haircut, implemented through an increased capital requirement). Whether 20% contingent h/c is a high enough number is a value judgement and I don't really have view.
The rally in bank shares on the news of the French plan says differently.
Banks that loaded up on Greek paper in the 90s have already profited handsomely (and the bankers received their bonuses for such a long time ago) as that stuff was trading at a wide spread to German then.
.