Quote from smallStops:
sometimes one has to tell it as it is:
justtrading you were wrong as far as Ghost of Cutten is concerned.
A sincere apology for having a strong ego - not good for trading - does not cost much and goes a long way.
As far as I can read through the lines, Ghost of Cutten knows his stuff and articulates it in a very clear way. Some here - including myself - are looking for people who can challenge the way we see things so as to see where we can improve more.
Thanks for thinking of others.
As you have done me the courtesy of explaining your position, I will do the same.
We do need to be clear on something first. There seems to be a great deal of tribal instinct at play here, of the sort you see in street gangs, cults and North Korea. Dear Leader must not be criticized it seems.
The reason apparently is because GoC is a good trader who knows his stuff, etc etc. I'll take your word that such is the case, but have to disagree that everything he says should be accepted without criticism. Tiger Woods and Sergio Garcia have achieved a great deal of success in life, yet both have been heavily criticized lately. It doesn't matter who you are, if you are wrong, you are wrong.
You may think me unkind for saying he is weak and dependent. Well, how about this gem from another thread?
....I can stop saving if I am dating a manic-spending woman, etc._
..... A frugal woman can get me to save more.
I think you know what one would typically say to a man like that, but I refrained. Lo and behold, he shows up here with this gem;
So, if you are a very disciplined loner, and happy to chug along earning your keep without ever getting close to realising your full potential, then trading solo may be for you.
It would appear that the fawning fanboys have stoked his hubris to the point where GoC honestly thinks that what may be good for him is good for everyone else. No one can be better than him, so if he can't do something, nobody else can.
As to what you see as my strong ego, I beg to differ. I'm not going to blow my own trumpet, suffice to say I have achieved success in life. I did that through leading by example. That required a healthy awareness of my strengths and weaknesses, and working to eliminate my weaknesses. It meant setting the highest standards for myself and holding myself to them. I had to be self-motivated because I was the one who was supposed to motivate everyone else.
The world would not be what it is today if we all quietly accepted it when people said "it can't be done". Having a healthy appreciation of ones own abilities and refusing to go along when people say it can't be done is not ego, it is common sense.
So no, there will be no apology to that self-appointed know it all who has the temerity to proclaim what others can and can't achieve on their own.