Quote from Look4aSine:
I think you confuse "uncertain outcome" with your "uncertain profit/loss".
The stock market has many certainties, all of which have nothing to do with your P/L.
Here are the basics:
1) Stocks go up.
2) Stocks go down.
3) Stocks go flat.
4) Stocks never go up forever.
5) Stocks never go down forever.
6) Stocks never stay flat forever.
7) Stocks transition from going up, down, or flat."
Enron's stock went down and stayed down.
GM's stock went down and stayed down.
So did the stock of Bear sterns, Lehman Brothers, Pacific Gas & Electric, Thornburg Mortgage, Chrysler, MF Global, Refco, Conseco, CIT Group, WorldCom, Washington Mutual, and American Airlines (several times) and hundreds, hundreds, of other publically traded companies.
I am not the one who is confused. You wish to tie the concept of "control" and "lack of control" to gambling." You cannot do so and stay in the discussion because the term "Gambling" has nothing to do with control. It is simply wagering something of value on an uncertain outcome. Of course, since the outcome is uncertain, you do not control it, otherwise it would be a certain outcome.
Your problem, as clearly evidenced in your version of the way way the stock market works, (which for you is a stock market full of "certainties,") is that you truly do not understand risk other than in binary terms - to you something is either a complete risk with a 100% chance of failure or it is somehow completely risk-free with a 100% chance of success.
Quote from Look4aSine:
"Control" or lack of "control" makes something gambling.
There you go again. Gambling is about wagering on the inherent uncertainty in the world, whether the outcome of a stock offering, the turn of card, the roll of the dice, a sporting event, a presidential election, the price of crude oil in May 2014.