So how did it turn out Kam? Did you get the job?
I just read this thread and found it pretty interesting. I was surprised by your initial pride toward Lefty's remarks(even if I disagree with some of them), but glad that you apologized to him nonetheless. Whether you agree or not, you are better served by really listening to his perspective.
I don't know if you are still having interviews, but I'll give you my piece of advice. And just so you know, I work at a fund that is in the same arena as Evolution, in fact I know a guy who just moved over from a sellside desk in Tokyo to a buyside fund in Hawaii, who knows, maybe it is Evolution. From the first interview, you should try to feel out your prospective employers and determine what it is they really want in a candidate. Each hedge fund manager is different, and each will gravitate toward various aspects of people. While Lefty's point about an employer wanting a prospective hire to be able to add value is definitely true, for a recent college grad looking to join a hedge fund, this is difficult. The key to landing any job or just conjuring good relations is to find chemistry between you and the employer. Regardless of what you know about the biz, some traits that I think will help you getting in at a fund are determination, stamina, passion for financial markets, and amicability. These are not things that can be learned(though, to some extent, they can be embellished or faked - however I don't recommend this).
Lastly and unrelated, I'd agree with Ozzy. Go off on your own. That's what I'm going to do now.A hedge fund isn't a good place for a new grad to learn IMO.