maybe I missed it... I am not sure you ever produced any peer reviewed science showing man made co2 causes warming. I remember you asking me to define peer reviewed... and I said in a peer reviewed journal but I was wiling to look at other things that involved real science an not failed models.
If I recall you produced something from Hansen about historical data - models and tipping points... but he presented no science showing man made co2 causes warming if I recall.
so before you claim to be repeating yourself... you should first link to some peer reviewed science.
2. I don't get this response. Change in Ocean temps leads co2 by one year... and change in Air temps is the leads by 9 months.
Are you claiming the leader is somehow really following the laggard? On what basis are you making that claim?
3. So I guess your speculation is that we are fast approaching a tipping point. Which is possible... but why are you saying that man made co2 is causing it. Do you have any science supporting that.. other than failed models.
seriously... I want to know what you think you have in terms of real science.
are you falling for the fake consensus crap?
is it models?
is it simply the idea that co2 can reflect can be a blanket... and a shield.
I think you are smart guy... but I wonder how well you analyze things.
its plain as day to most really smart people there is no peer reviewed science showing man made co2 is causing warming... its speculation.
I can submit a list of thousand of scientists who question the consensus.
Did you read what Freeman Dyson is saying. He is a top scientist known for his critical thinking skills.
The idea that global warming is the most important problem facing the world is total nonsense and is doing a lot of harm.
Freeman Dyson, American physicist
I have already answered this question. Unlike Futurecurrents, I don't have the patience to say the same thing over and over again, thinking that somehow this umpteenth different way of explaining it will somehow hit home with the person.
That CO2 levels also have some correlation to ocean temperatures does not surprise me, since the oceans are a vast stores of all sorts of elements, greenhouse gas or not. Since water is special and there is almost nothing else like it, the effect of the oceans is to dampen any accumulation of these chemicals.
At some point though, there is a tipping point where water can no longer work its magic. We are approaching that faster than ever because other than natural processes that dump chemicals into the ocean, we are now a significant part in addition to that. The oceans can't keep up for much longer. If it weren't for the Earths oceans, the Earth would already be Venus.