I very carefully read every post in this thread.
My response is long and I'll understand if folks don't want to slog through a diatribe like this. I've spent years in here throwing bombs so I guess my reputation isn't for deep thought or constructive ideas. I'll understand.
It is possible to literally sense Tsing Tao's sadness from his post. He is genuinely disappointed with our country and concerned for his children. He is disillusioned with the family members and friends who blindly voted for our destruction. He is questioning his relationships with those people. He is wondering if there is a better place to live. He is a little uncomfortable about taking money from the system. It was a tough read because Tsing Tao is a strong and frighteningly smart man and it made me feel awful to see him soul-searching like this. It really isn't about his own comfort or materialism, it seems to be all about his kids and their future IMHO.
I also saw a couple of people taking pleasure in TT's anguish. Ricter's posts were the most notable for this. I have mentioned that I like Ricter and I felt genuine concern for him when he had gone missing for a short time. He is interesting and I was fascinated when he was setting up his farm and thought I could get to know him. Lately is has become evident that he despises me personally and that he hates most of the people in P&R who harbor conservative political views. Ricter used to transcend those differences and was regarded as a constructive debater if somewhat cryptic. I think he has changed and I sincerely hope it isn't due to illness or anything bad going on in his life. People get older and sometimes they get mean. Or maybe he has just decided that it is futile to try to win hearts and minds in this place. I might be doing the same thing.
First, the People Problem. Over the last few years I've been confronted with some friends and family members who have so thoroughly screwed up their lives that my continued interaction with them became a threat to my happiness and economic stability. It was my father who had to clue me in as to what to do about these toxic people. Its simple, toxic people get thrown out of my life. There simply isn't room in my heart or my bankbook for them. I can tolerate someone being a liberal (my fiancée voted for Obama) but if they are in my face about it they are tossed out of my life. My fiancée offered to vote for Romney/Ryan when I made it clear how important it was to me but in the end I thought she should vote the way her heart told her to and she did. She is starting to ask the right questions though. The point is that she was interested in being a partner and was listening to me and not being a toxic person. There are others in my family that get in my face about being conservative and I'm simply no longer going to attend family functions. Toxic means that a person has become a financial burden or an emotional burden. It can mean that they are a bad influence on your family or yourself. Toxic can mean simply that a person is enthusiastically voting for ideas that threaten your lifestyle or threaten the future of your kids. I'm not saying that your mother is toxic because you send her a little money every month. But if, say, she was making constant large and unreasonable demands for money and that money was essential for you to pay your own bills and she obviously didn't care what effect it had on your family then she might be considered to be toxic. Toxic people have to go. Life is short.
One philosophical question that is repeated through this thread is the notion of "taking". The idea is that if we are clearly a producer in the USA we're going to have our assets looted while people who aren't producers will take from our economy in the form of housing assistance, food EBT, non-food EBT, utility assistance, free access to communications (phone, internet), transportation assistance, disability pensions and a tax system that will put a heavy burden on the producers and give the takers a pass. My personal view is that if you are close to retirement and have tucked your assets away out of sight then there is no reason you shouldn't get some of the free stuff that is available.
An long time friend of mine is living in an absolutely free 2 bedroom condo that is about 10 years old and located in a nice neighborhood. She doesn't pay for electric power or water. She has a foster child that she cares for and receives a surprising amount of cash for his care. She does not pay any income tax. She receives an EBT card (foodstamps basically) for food and another EBT card for things like gasoline, clothing, non-food items. She gets food assistance from another program relating to the foster child that supplies milk, fruit, cereal and other specific food items. Her foster child is picked up daily by bus and taken to Head Start where he is fed twice and plays with other kids. She and her foster son both receive completely free medical care with no co-payment and free prescription drugs. She just received a free cellular phone (yep, an Obamaphone) and has 250 minutes free time per month. She has an internet connection for free that is reasonably fast. She seems to be a professional mom and I was stunned at how nice her place is. It is immaculate and spacious with park-like green spaces just out the back door and no gang-bangers or obvious drug dealers or lowlifes hanging around on the corner or anywhere that I saw.
continued...