I tend to agree.
@carrer , do you have any proof that @J_Smith is an accomplished trader? Having just discovered this thread, and being familiar now with the poetry that J_S likes to recite instead of just making his points clear, I am suspicious of what exactly he is trying to do. So far, he cannot even explain what 0 +1 -1 means from the other thread, and he writes poetry to try and explain things.
If you will actually attempt to learn from this individual, don't you think you need things to be a little more clear? He states above that he wants to see exactly how you are trading, where your entries were, time, P&L, why you entered the trade, etc. which are all good points, but has he shown you any of this with regards to his own trading? Why can he be so specific and direct with actual trades, and be a total prick when explaining something, which is in no way an explanation? He may state that he doesn't want vendors to see what is going on, but could it also not be that he doesn't want others to call him out on the bullshit that he tries to spread?
Seriously, what proof do you have that this guy can help you? ET is littered with gurus that teach, and not a single one of them has ever produced a student who trades profitably. Worst of all, no guru has ever produced any evidence that they are trading profitably themselves, never mind even that they have an ability to teach.
If @J_Smith wants to put some of these issues to rest, I'm sure you would welcome him sharing this in your journal. When most people apply for a job, they share a resume of their previous work experience and the new company will undoubebtly call the previous employers to verify that this individual was a good employee. I think J_Smith should provide you with some of this before you waste your time.
Mind your own businesses, they are not children.
GPUAR
And for any more of ye, who think ye know it all..here ye go


CR, you now see why email is the only way, way too many idiots on these forums
J_S