Carrer's PnL (The Journey of a Poor Trader)

@J_Smith

Going through your message history, perhaps it would be nice if the former guys you tried to help can vouch for you. You don't want to share anything about your own trades, or how you trade, or your P&L, essentially nothing to give you some credibility, but I see you tried helping some previous posters in the past so perhaps they can vouch for you.

There was @Yukoner in this thread here: http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index...-jsmith-discuss-feel-free-to-weigh-in.290107/

And then there also was @JoshLowe005 in this thread here: http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index.php?threads/mentoring-jl.294483/
 
tt.texantrader said:
@J_Smith

Going through your message history, perhaps it would be nice if the former guys you tried to help can vouch for you. You don't want to share anything about your own trades, or how you trade, or your P&L, essentially nothing to give you some credibility, but I see you tried helping some previous posters in the past so perhaps they can vouch for you.

There was @Yukoner in this thread here: http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index...-jsmith-discuss-feel-free-to-weigh-in.290107/

And then there also was @JoshLowe005 in this thread here: http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index.php?threads/mentoring-jl.294483/
More...

As I said previously, mind your own business.

If you guys want to help anyone, if ye are able, that is, then off ye go, and don't worry, I will not be bothering ye, as I don't waste my time with idiots!

GPUAR:finger::D

J_S
 
J_Smith said:
As I said previously, mind your own business.

If you guys want to help anyone, if ye are able, that is, then off ye go, and don't worry, I will not be bothering ye, as I don't waste my time with idiots!

GPUAR:finger::D

J_S
More...
So what you're saying is that you have no desire to state publicly why anyone should believe you, and that if anyone questions you, they should mind their own business? And on top of this, we are idiots for asking you to show why you are qualified to give help? Simply incredible.
 
tt.texantrader said:
So what you're saying is that you have no desire to state publicly why anyone should believe you, and that if anyone questions you, they should mind their own business? And on top of this, we are idiots for asking you to show why you are qualified to give help? Simply incredible.
More...

What I am saying is that i don't give a shite what you, or anyone else, thinks about what I do, or say, for it is my business.

CR will tell people here if I ask him for money, but he is clever enough to know I am not one of those fools who try to dupe people, in fact, I despise such people, fukin dim wits who think they have it all worked out, and yet, have to resort to taking money from others.

They are all a bunch of morons, no exceptions!

And don't think you will ever see any detail of what I speak about, for, I will make it my business to make sure no muppet gets any of my work to use.

So, once again, get lost, and mind your own business:finger::D

J_S
 
tt.texantrader said:
I tend to agree.

@carrer , do you have any proof that @J_Smith is an accomplished trader? Having just discovered this thread, and being familiar now with the poetry that J_S likes to recite instead of just making his points clear, I am suspicious of what exactly he is trying to do. So far, he cannot even explain what 0 +1 -1 means from the other thread, and he writes poetry to try and explain things.

If you will actually attempt to learn from this individual, don't you think you need things to be a little more clear? He states above that he wants to see exactly how you are trading, where your entries were, time, P&L, why you entered the trade, etc. which are all good points, but has he shown you any of this with regards to his own trading? Why can he be so specific and direct with actual trades, and be a total prick when explaining something, which is in no way an explanation? He may state that he doesn't want vendors to see what is going on, but could it also not be that he doesn't want others to call him out on the bullshit that he tries to spread?

Seriously, what proof do you have that this guy can help you? ET is littered with gurus that teach, and not a single one of them has ever produced a student who trades profitably. Worst of all, no guru has ever produced any evidence that they are trading profitably themselves, never mind even that they have an ability to teach.

If @J_Smith wants to put some of these issues to rest, I'm sure you would welcome him sharing this in your journal. When most people apply for a job, they share a resume of their previous work experience and the new company will undoubebtly call the previous employers to verify that this individual was a good employee. I think J_Smith should provide you with some of this before you waste your time.
More...

Not true, it was explained clearly to me:

http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index.php?threads/either-its-1-or-0.298785/page-5#post-4264407
 
carrer said:
@tt.texantrader and @Turveyd
I will give it a try. Like J_Smith said, if anything goes wrong I will update here.
More...

Its not just after your money, it's the filling your head with some crap that he believes to stroke his own ego, he will lie to you that it works and him self while still losing money.

Seen it about a 1000 times sadly. I started off profitable then i listened to fools how to really do it, lost most of my money, learnt went back to basics did well, till day trader rulers crippled me :(


Share the secret when he finally gets around to telling it you, so we can all have a good laugh.
 
You will never get the real secret, for I have mentioned that previously, and it will go to my grave with me, for, when I give my word to someone, I keep it, not like most of ye 2 faced idiots out there.

It has been made very clear, no illusions, and if you are unable to read, or understand, then you are even thicker than you sound:rolleyes:

As repeated many times, it is idiots like you that cost people money, as ye talk out yere arses, and it is obvious that ye haven't a clue about trading:finger::D

J_S
 
J_Smith said:
You will never get the real secret, for I have mentioned that previously, and it will go to my grave with me, for, when I give my word to someone, I keep it, not like most of ye 2 faced idiots out there.

It has been made very clear, no illusions, and if you are unable to read, or understand, then you are even thicker than you sound:rolleyes:

As repeated many times, it is idiots like you that cost people money, as ye talk out yere arses, and it is obvious that ye haven't a clue about trading:finger::D

J_S
More...

But............

I post my setups I'm trying, my logic behind and my rules in my journal, no secrets!

Ohhh and most of my trades live, ( when at PC not on tablet not enough screens )

I have good and bad times, but overall I'm slightly profitable, aiming for better.

Where as you have just proved you can talk the talk, but none of above.


So proof to all you can trade ( live calls only accepted as proof ), or stop scamming.
 
J_Smith said:
You will never get the real secret, for I have mentioned that previously, and it will go to my grave with me, for, when I give my word to someone, I keep it, not like most of ye 2 faced idiots out there.

It has been made very clear, no illusions, and if you are unable to read, or understand, then you are even thicker than you sound:rolleyes:

As repeated many times, it is idiots like you that cost people money, as ye talk out yere arses, and it is obvious that ye haven't a clue about trading:finger::D

J_S
More...

So if I'm never going to get the 'secret' then you aren't going to risk sharing it with Carrer, so logically its all BS and there is no secret, thats just a carrot you dangle.


Is the 'secret' to go on forums pretending to help people, which attracts PM interest from others which are desperate so you can take there money, it is isn't it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top