Your point is very well taken from the standpoint of "Trade what you see, not what you think." Markets go where they want, logic notwithstanding.Quote from trader_arb:
Does it matter though? Serious question. If the market rallies on bad unemployment with little chance of improvement, would black friday sales- which are hard to quantify to begin with, make a difference? I'm sure theres some BS reason for a rally, or no reason such as excess liquidity (thanks fed).
I speak more from a macro perspective.
