Bill Maher: Americans must realize what makes NFL football so great: socialism.

Yes. That's the point I was making in my original post. The NFL analogy with socialism makes no sense. The teams do what puts the most money in their pockets. With lots of teams, you could spread a lot of wealth around to many teams and players (socialism), but all the existing owners and players would suffer. They won't do it because they are monopolistic capitalists, not socialists.


Quote from blackjack007:

they don't have 100 teams because the talent level would be so diluted that fans would be less interested overall.
 
Quote from Ricter:
... Maher's implicit argument, that if socialism works for an enterprise like the NFL, it could work for an enterprise like the United States therefore doesn't hold up.
Quote from tomdavis:
...The NFL analogy with socialism makes no sense...

Therefore I have concluded Bill Maher is an idiot.
 
Quote from Petsamo:

The Houston Oilers and Baltimore Colts left. Now those two cities regained NFL teams. If big sports teams leave a city, there's a huge vacuum in tax revenues. I don't expect you leftists to understand. Why am I arguing with you. You leftists don't know how to run a country or city.
chair1.gif


I'm a leftist? Are you being sarcastic? I don't think any city should be allowed to force taxpayers to build a stadium to play a lame game. Any city. Understand? That's why they keep leaving or threatening to leave. Call it extortion. They never used to leave or threaten to leave decades ago and everything was finer.
 
Quote from bone:
Martin, that is news to me and I stand corrected.

I must also report that the US National Hockey League has lots of Russkies.
Yep, the original NHL Russkies were the old guard that played for CSKA Moscow (the Soviet Army team, which got to cherry pick the best and the brightest).
 
Quote from bone:
I must also report that the US National Hockey League has lots of Russkies.
Capitalism and money attract players from all countries, no boundaries. Russkies can't make the money in their motherland, so they join the imperialist Americans.

The NBA has players from many countries. Sammy Sosa came from the Dominican Republic. US coaches couldn't make Doug Flute tick so he went to Canada where he became a star quarterback. Michael Jordan came from Africa, etc etc.

Players don't get the big money from socialist and communist countries, so they come here.
 
Back
Top