Another HUGELY successful $$$MR. MARKET$$$ pick

[Grob109]

Quote from mrmarket:



Actually I thought it was a really good analysis also. The only thing I would have done differently would have been to summarize the total gains over the period. 12.6% per trade over 53 trades is a pretty big number when compounded.

However it is his analysis and he is entitled to present it any way he wants and I commend him on taking the time to do the analysis and to form an objective conclusion.

Why don't you simply do that different thing?

To turn your 15 stream portfolio over just once takes 15 (count 'em) successful pics. That makes 15% on your capital.

Do it on the average of every 5 weeks (4 to 6 weeks) for four months.

That is what you are offering. There is a PnL in your past threds that you can gut to save you some time.

Want me to post a pic of my old U of P grad faculty ID card? Post yours. Then when I post mine it will confirm mine is the same. (almost, except for the faculty part on mine.).

Thanks to those who squared phoenix away. Once he looks around a little he will see the methodology and analysis back up. It's alot more comprehensive than he, apparently has ever seen based on the fawning he does of big boy.

 

[inandlong]

Quote from dbphoenix:



Hardly. Anybody can post a list of stocks. At least MrMarket provides criteria and analysis. Whether one agrees with them or not is something else altogether.

The methods are altogether different really. There is no portfolio to post per se. And the method seeks to turn stocks over every 6-8 days. It would be like asking someone who trades the NQ that is offering critique on a stockpicking method to post his portfolio. Or even better, asking someone who is exploring the NRID trade (moi) to post a portfolio. All I can do is post the stocks that presently qualify for the setup. But it wouldn't mean I could not offer criticism or critique about another method. Which in the case of mrmarket I can't because relative to his work, I don't know squat.

I received an email last nite from a well-known guy I communicate with. He told me he wished ET were a kinder and gentler place. So do I.

 

[mrmarket]

Quote from inandlong:

The methods are altogether different really. There is no portfolio to post per se. And the method seeks to turn stocks over every 6-8 days. It would be like asking someone who trades the NQ that is offering critique on a stockpicking method to post his portfolio. Or even better, asking someone who is exploring the NRID trade (moi) to post a portfolio. All I can do is post the stocks that presently qualify for the setup. But it wouldn't mean I could not offer criticism or critique about another method. Which in the case of mrmarket I can't because relative to his work, I don't know squat.

I received an email last nite from a well-known guy I communicate with. He told me he wished ET were a kinder and gentler place. So do I.

Me too. I think I have a proven successful method that makes lots of money. I never said that the methods espoused by others were not successful. However, when some ET people view my unbelievable success, they feel the need to shoot me down. Weird.

 

[dbphoenix]

Quote from inandlong:

The methods are altogether different really. There is no portfolio to post per se. And the method seeks to turn stocks over every 6-8 days. It would be like asking someone who trades the NQ that is offering critique on a stockpicking method to post his portfolio. Or even better, asking someone who is exploring the NRID trade (moi) to post a portfolio. All I can do is post the stocks that presently qualify for the setup. But it wouldn't mean I could not offer criticism or critique about another method. Which in the case of mrmarket I can't because relative to his work, I don't know squat.

Apparently, neither does Jack. Which is why I wonder what qualifies him to take potshots. Smugness does not imply competence.

 

[demonet]

mrmarket wrote:


Me too. I think I have a proven successful method that makes lots of money. I never said that the methods espoused by others were not successful. However, when some ET people view my unbelievable success, they feel the need to shoot me down. Weird.

I have read this thread and others in which you have posted, and I think its the fact that you constantly shout out "I am having unbelieveable success with my method". In effect you are making a clarion call to everyone saying "come admire me for my stock picking talent as it is so dazzlingly brilliant and successful". From that people just start out motivated to tear you and your method down because your sound so pompous.

Its just my opinion mrmarket, but perhaps you would get far less flak if you just took a more humble approach. For instance, you could post your stocklist and your methods for selection (or a sketch thereof), and say "this has worked pretty well for me, what do you think?". That way you could engage in a more intelligent discussion of the potential pros and cons of your method.

Lastly, when you defend yourself, you immediately say things like the quote above, i.e. "I am just doing everything right and those who do things wrong (and are jealous of how smart and rich I am) just shoot me down..." This just makes the situation worse, and I can't understand why you don't see that. You sound like an nine-year-old bragging to his friends how he can hit a baseball farther than anyone else.

I think, simply stated, its the arrogance of your posts which offend people, not the means and methods of your stock picking talent or even your alleged success.

[size=2.5] inandlong wrote:


I received an email last nite from a well-known guy I communicate with. He told me he wished ET were a kinder and gentler place. So do I.[/size]

Me too. If this board were comprised of Schwager's 'Market Wizards', do you think they would engage in this petty tearing down of one another's methods?

 

[inandlong]

Quote from dbphoenix:

Smugness does not imply competence.

LOL!

I always hope I'm just reading it wrong, you know how the printed word can seem different than intended sometimes.

 

[inandlong]

Quote from demonet:

I think, simply stated, its the arrogance of your posts which offend people, not the means and methods of your stock picking talent or even your alleged success.

Agreed.

If this board were comprised of Schwager's 'Market Wizards', do you think they would engage in this petty tearing down of one another's methods?

No, but you can rest assured the non-Market Wizard members would do their best to take up the slack.

 

[mrmarket]

Quote from demonet:



I have read this thread and others in which you have posted, and I think its the fact that you constantly shout out "I am having unbelieveable success with my method". In effect you are making a clarion call to everyone saying "come admire me for my stock picking talent as it is so dazzlingly brilliant and successful". From that people just start out motivated to tear you and your method down because your sound so pompous.

Its just my opinion mrmarket, but perhaps you would get far less flak if you just took a more humble approach. For instance, you could post your stocklist and your methods for selection (or a sketch thereof), and say "this has worked pretty well for me, what do you think?". That way you could engage in a more intelligent discussion of the potential pros and cons of your method.

Lastly, when you defend yourself, you immediately say things like the quote above, i.e. "I am just doing everything right and those who do things wrong (and are jealous of how smart and rich I am) just shoot me down..." This just makes the situation worse, and I can't understand why you don't see that. You sound like an nine-year-old bragging to his friends how he can hit a baseball farther than anyone else.

I think, simply stated, its the arrogance of your posts which offend people, not the means and methods of your stock picking talent or even your alleged success.

I think I'm pretty funny actually. I also think people take life too seriously but I respect the fact that you are entitled to your opinion.

 

[mrmarket]

By the way, they are lapping me up over at the IBD forum.

 

[dbphoenix]

Quote from mrmarket:

By the way, they are lapping me up over at the IBD forum.

And, according to Jack, they're lapping him up over at MSN.

That's a lot of lapping.