"Sitting on your ass and refusing to work just doesn't cut it as 'heroism' in my book."
Yes, you have your own book which you read and write in.
Ali was attacked for refusing military induction, called every name in the book.
Some continue to view him that way, others view his refusal to fight in the Vietnam war as heroic.
Some view his boxing as barbaric, other view his boxing skills and championships as heroic.
Some viewed his willingness to speak his mind in the 60's as just some "loud mouthed "nigger" who should keep his damn mouth shut" and others viewed him as a hero.
There are many "books" in a democratic society."
____________________________
If your "book" misses the point of the analogy of Nuremberg, then you miss that point of rationalizing behavior that you think, feel, and believe is wrong with the justification of simply "following orders."
When we have a military who thinks that they are charged with blindly following a president, without any thinking process, then we have a robotic military who serves the favor of the president, not the intention of the constitution.
The Framers in no way intended for one single man to wield that type of power, especially military power, as they had a firm knowledge of history where the military became simply a tool for the ambition of a dictatorial leader.
That our wimpy congressional branch did not hold the executive branch's feet to the fire before this war is their failure to serve the will of the Framers, electing instead to act in a manner to preserve their jobs when viewing the electorates knee jerk reaction to 9/11.
_________________________
Gandhi sat and did little but spin cotton on a spinning wheel and resist the British authority in a non violent manner, was that bravery?
In your "book" apparently not...
Quote from Rearden Metal:
I'm not sure why dozens of posts went by without anyone pointing this out, but do you know <b>what kinds of acts the Nuremberg war criminals were accused of committing?</b> None of them were charged with the simple act of 'being deployed to occupied territory', I can assure you.
You know how Lt. Watada <b>could</b> have made himself into a hero? By deploying to Iraq as ordered and carefully supervising the troops under his command, making sure his men respect the human rights of all the locals they come into contact with, while working hard out in the field to avert the next Haditha massacre from taking place.
Now <b>that</b> would have been heroic. Heroism takes hard work. Sitting on your ass and refusing to work just doesn't cut it as 'heroism' in my book.